A blog post from the Electronic Frontier Foundation makes the case that the United States is jeopardizing its position in the worldwide cloud-computing market by failing to provide the kinds of privacy assurances demanded by international laws.
Moreover, the authors contend that U.S. officials are speaking out of both sides of their mouths on the issue.
From the post:
On January 18, a senior Justice Department official tried to reassure companies and people around the world that hosting their data in the United States creates no increased privacy risk for them from the US government. Deputy Assistant Attorney General Bruce Swartz noted: "Cloud computing has important advantages to consumers (but) doesn't present any issues that have not always been present. Certainly not regarding Internet service issues, but even before that."
Apparently, the DOJ is reacting to decisions by foreign entities to drop US-based services due to concerns about US government access, including British company BAE dropping Microsoft Office 365 and the Dutch government's hesitation about allowing its contractors to use US-based cloud services. In the past, Denmark and Canada have also voiced their concerns about the level of protection the United States can provide to their citizens' data. EU public tenders of cloud services are also avoiding US cloud services for the same reasons. European-based companies, which have to comply with EU data protection law, see this opportunity as a competitive advantage, as do Australian cloud services.
Yet the DOJ's reassurances ring hollow. While the DOJ may spin its position one way to try to appease foreign audiences, its actual position is quite clear where it really matters: in US courts when it is trying to access subscriber information held by US-based cloud computing services. Indeed, the DOJ's position in its court filings is that very little, if any, privacy protection is available against US government access to the records of users of US-based cloud computing services.
Actions speak louder than words, of course, and right now the actions of the U.S. government aren't doing the providers of online services any favors.
Welcome regulars and passersby. Here are a few more recent buzzblog items. And, if you’d like to receive Buzzblog via e-mail newsletter, here’s where to sign up. You can follow me on Twitter here and on Google+ here.
- 2012’s 25 Geekiest 25th Anniversaries.
- Supreme Court backs privacy over police in GPS case.
- Who’s flying drones in U.S.? … FAA won’t say.
- Slashdotters rain on “cloud computing”
- “The Joy of Books” tap dances all over your Kindle.
- Who’s lying? The iPad owner or the border guard?
- Survey shows we need a better definition of paperless.
- “LAN-party house” guy spills important details.
- Follow the Mythbusters' bouncing cannonball.
- Steve Jobs and his gadgets … in LEGO.
- Maybe you can trash your boss online after all.
- Blue Screen of Death gets a new look in Windows 8.