Google productivity tools still looking to impress corporate users

Strides made in past year, but work still remains

While Google is often cited as having a golden touch, the company's productivity application suite is still a mere bronze competitor to Microsoft's Office and collaboration tools despite upgrades over the past year that focused on evolving and securing the online tools for corporate users.

Google Apps Premier Edition (GAPE), the vendor's $50 per user productivity suite targeted at businesses, has proven worthy in certain situations, most involving universities or small and midsize businesses (SMB) looking to cut costs.

The platform, however, still lacks some key features for large companies that build applications around productivity tools and demand tight integration and security, along with administrative controls.

GAPE is made up of messaging, including Google Gmail, Calendars and Talk; collaboration including Google Docs, Video and Sites; and e-mail security and compliance.

Google's strengths and weaknesses.

Over the past year, Google has been adding tools and APIs to satisfy customer demands, as well as Web 2.0 tools such as video that put a new twist on collaboration. But the work is far from over.

Model for success

Even critics, however, believe Google has the right model to succeed — delivering the software as a service to corporate users.

Microsoft, whose Office suite boasts more than a 90% share of the market, is among those critics.

It endorsed the online model in October when it introduced the first online versions of fully functional Office applications available via a browser. Office Web Applications are in private testing and are slated for inclusion with Office 14. Microsoft already has its toe in the water with Office Live Workspaces and with Exchange and SharePoint Online Services.

While the future may hold promise, the current position for GAPE is the role of worthy alternative and not as serious contender to replace Office or other collaboration platforms.

Google, however, may make its mark not by rising to the top of the heap, but by redefining collaboration and carving the most innovative turns around Web 2.0.

Growing up

"The Google model is not wrong, it is just immature," says Guy Creese, a Burton Group analyst who for years has been tracking Google's efforts to produce online productivity tools. This month he is releasing a report entitled: "Is It Time to Ditch Microsoft Office?"

It is an interesting question because Google isn't lagging for lack of trying.

The company is refining its platform to include new features and controls that appeal to — and are required by — corporate users. And it is adding Web 2.0 twists and integrating social software.

In July 2007, Google made its biggest investment yet toward satisfying corporate users when it laid out $625 million for e-mail hygiene vendor Postini, which provided the compliance, archiving and e-mail protection GAPE lacked.

The Postini service provides security for e-mail, instant messaging and the Web; archiving; message encryption; and policy enforcement of Transport Layer Security.

And because Postini's archiving and compliance only covers e-mail, Google last month released an API to address documents.

"We let you connect your Google Docs with the others systems you use for compliance," says Rajen Sheth, senior product manager for Google Apps. "We continue to mature the product set."

To further back that claim, Sheth also cites the addition of Google Sites, a wiki-based team sharing tool, and Google Video, based on capabilities inherited from its YouTube division.

Google also has added an service-level agreement and is working on an administrative dashboard that shows how its systems are running and their health. The tool comes after a string of outages that crippled GAPE in the past months.

And in November, Google earned its SAS-70 Type II certification, which public companies under the Sarbanes Oxley Act require from their hosting providers.

In addition, Google and its partners are busy ratcheting up the feature set, such as Panorama Software, which has developed a slick — and free — business intelligence tool called Analytics for Google Spreadsheets.

"This is not about replacing, it is about solving old problems in new ways with Google Docs," says Oudi Antebi, vice president of strategy for Panorama. Antebi, who came to Panorama after eight years at Microsoft, says one reason for lagging enterprise interest in GAPE is that many are looking at it as a replacement instead of an extension to what they already have.

Seeing is believing

One example of Google's potential power is seen in the District of Columbia government, which is using Google's productivity suite to foster cost reduction, anywhere access, mobile integration and a collaboration platform that evolves on Internet time for its 38,000 employees.

Vivek Kundra, the CTO for the D.C. government, is blazing such a path with his Google-based projects. He is rumored to be helping President-elect Barack Obama's transition team work through its technology agenda focused on "cutting-edge technologies to create a new level of transparency, accountability and participation for America's citizens."

Kundra's innovations around Google Apps include a video job board, where D.C. hiring managers post descriptions of openings; a wiki built with text and video explaining and soliciting participation in D.C.'s procurement process; and his latest project where he has provided a list of contractors D.C. has hired, the projects they are working on and their pay rates.  

"What we have created is transparency," Kundra says. "Taxpayers can hold us accountable."

Kundra also launched Apps for Democracy, a contest to build applications on top of the Google platform using any of the 216 data feeds from the D.C. Data Catalog, including most recent road-kill pickups.

The contest yielded 47 applications in 30 days at a cost of $50,000. Kundra estimated the price would have been $2.6 million if done using D.C.'s old form of in-house development. Seven of the applications are now running in production.

"This is the power [you get] when you greatly democratize the ability to create, publish and distribute content," Kundra says. "Before, you relied on a massive IT operation with developers, Web editors and writers. Now we shift power to the individual employee."

But Kundra recognizes Google Apps also has its weaknesses.

D.C. still uses Microsoft Office, which he says is better suited for creating complex documents, and he is still waiting for Google integration with Exchange calendars.

Climbing the mountain

One barrier to Google's success is the fact that it is a crowded race to become second fiddle and take a run at Microsoft's dominance.

Since launching GAPE in February 2007, Google has earned $4 million compared with $12.2 billion for Microsoft's Office, according to Gartner. Google won't clarify its number of paid users other than to say it has "hundreds of thousands."

And there are a host of other competitors including IBM Lotus Symphony, Corel WordPerfect Office,, Sun StarOffice, ThinkFree and Zoho, as well as lesser known vendors such as Ability Office, Celframe Office, Koffice, GNOME Office and Softmaker Office.

In a study released last month, ClickStream found that use of free versions of productivity tools such as Google Docs and OpenOffice remain low and that use of Microsoft Office showed no decline.

ClickStream spent six months tracking usage among 2,400 adults using the tools at home and found that 51% used Microsoft Office, while only 5% used Open Office, 1% used Google Docs and 0.3% Google Spreadsheets.

ClickStream concluded that "although Google Docs and Spreadsheets has been touted as a potential competitor to the Microsoft Office suite, OpenOffice is currently the more likely app to take that position, possibly indicating the value of offline and local processing enabled by installed applications."

What's missing?

Critics and Google agree there is work to do.

Burton Group's Creese says Google provides only rudimentary e-mail distribution lists, lacks the ability to do administration via roles, and does not support Office 2007 file formats.

"If you standardized on [Office 2007] you are in trouble," he says. The software also does not translate all graphics from Word documents, supports only a dozen or so fonts, does not provide in-box delegation features and imposes file size limitations when importing documents.

"If you are trying to collaborate on PowerPoint you could hit the limit," Creese says.

He thinks SMBs may be able to go completely to GAPE, but "a large corporation cannot do that. It will always have a mixed environment and you have to worry about these translation issues."

He adds that for Google Apps to take off it has to present new ways of working rather than just making software less expensive. "In the long run, we will see a movement to the software-as-a-service office suite in some form," he says.

Google's Sheth would not provide details of coming features for GAPE, but agreed with the list of issues cited by Creese and others. "I think we already have a robust enterprise offering, of course there is more we can do. We are building that list and adding more and more functionality," he says.

The challenge is clear to many.

"Google needs to keep innovating around new ways that people work," says Tony Safoian, president and CEO of SadaSystems, a consulting and development firm that is both a Microsoft and a Google partner. "I can work with five people at the same time on the same spreadsheet and get the work done. That is how people work today. Google needs to continue to move along the lines of the collaborative work environment where people find things in a few seconds instead of hours or days. That is where Google's edge is now."

SadaSystems has made a significant investment in building Google Apps implementations and will continue to move users to the cloud.

"We are betting big on this technology," Safoian says.

Now the question is whether corporate users bet big on Google and its innovations or stick with Microsoft as it moves to its hybrid world of software and services.

Learn more about this topic

Clear Choice Test: Google Apps

Google Apps goes to school a Notre Dame

Google adds analytics for Apps admins
Must read: 11 hidden tips and tweaks for Windows 10
View Comments
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies