An overlay approach is better than using a unified WLAN
Two industry insiders debate whether Wi-Fi should be deployed as an extension to the wired LAN.
Face-off
By Keerti Melkote
,
Network World
, 05/10/2004
- Share/Email
- Tweet This
- Print
Wireless networks are completely different from their wired brethren and should be treated as such. Merely adding wireless as a feature to
existing wired networks quickly turns into a security and management nightmare, for several reasons:
• Wireless networks are inherently insecure. Radio frequency waves penetrate walls and flow into parking lots. Locking the
RF environment is essential to maintaining the privacy of the enterprise network. That's only the beginning. All integral
components of a wireless network such as secure user authentication strong encryption, containing wireless intrusions and
rogue transmissions, and stateful firewalling can't be simply bolted onto the corporate intranet.
The other side by Vipin Jain
Face-off forum
Debate the issue with Jain and Melkote.
• RF spectrum is shared and dynamic. Wi-Fi's unlicensed spectrum is free to anyone for any application. Other radio frequency
sources, such as neighboring access points and cordless phones, can cause interference problems. Constant real-time monitoring
and radio frequency spectrum management is required to combat this reality. Self-calibrating wireless LAN (WLAN) capabilities
also are mandatory for operating a wireless network, including dynamic channel allocation and automatic power assignment,
interference detection and mitigation, self-healing and load balancing. Moreover, sharing the air requires the use of new
quality-of-service (QoS) mechanisms for prioritizing access to the medium along with methods that minimize jitter and maximize battery power for
handheld devices. Wired networks don't know or care about any of these requirements. Trying to incrementally add them disrupts
what already works.
• Wireless networks require mobility. An enterprise Wi-Fi network is like a cellular network in that roaming and seamless handoffs
are an implicit expectation. Like a cellular network that uses the IP network for transport, so should the WLAN. An enterprise
Wi-Fi user can roam across multiple LAN ports and multiple wired LAN switches in the network while staying connected to the
network. Ultimately, wired networks must aggregate user ports and deliver wire-speed transport for TCP/IP traffic. But Wi-Fi
networks need to process and forward traffic based on user identity, location and presence while delivering security, mobility,
RF spectrum management and QoS for emerging wireless applications.
Comment