Is network innovation dead?

Is there any innovation in the network marketplace anymore? There's a thundering silence as compared with a few short years ago, when every time you turned around there was a new protocol, a new product addressing unmet business needs, and a new forum to promote these new products.

Today, only three areas - VoIP, security and wireless - constantly generate news, and the rate of change in these areas has slowed over the past few years. Instead, we're seeing more emphasis on streamlining and economizing existing processes rather than inventing new ones. Have networks evolved to the point that there's nothing new to be done, so all that's left is to deliver services at the lowest possible cost?

Innovation is alive and well, but it also depends on how you define innovation. Innovation goes far beyond invention; it includes taking existing technologies, concepts and products, and combining them in a unique fashion. For example, Net6 is certainly innovative in taking now-standard SSL technology and expanding it from browser-based interfaces to encompass VoIP over SSL.

To continue reading, register here and become an Insider. You'll get free access to premium content from CIO, Computerworld, CSO, InfoWorld, and Network World. See more Insider content or sign in.

Is there any innovation in the network marketplace anymore? There's a thundering silence as compared with a few short years ago, when every time you turned around there was a new protocol, a new product addressing unmet business needs, and a new forum to promote these new products.

Today, only three areas - VoIP, security and wireless - constantly generate news, and the rate of change in these areas has slowed over the past few years. Instead, we're seeing more emphasis on streamlining and economizing existing processes rather than inventing new ones. Have networks evolved to the point that there's nothing new to be done, so all that's left is to deliver services at the lowest possible cost?

Innovation is alive and well, but it also depends on how you define innovation. Innovation goes far beyond invention; it includes taking existing technologies, concepts and products, and combining them in a unique fashion. For example, Net6 is certainly innovative in taking now-standard SSL technology and expanding it from browser-based interfaces to encompass VoIP over SSL.

Similarly, innovation can be used to solve a problem that innovation causes. Take wireless LANs (WLAN). The innovative 802.11 products from a few years ago work great as long as the footprints don't overlap. But they work so great that they also cause a problem - how to provide complete coverage over an entire campus while controlling access, providing roaming capabilities and avoiding interference. To solve this problem, companies such as Airespace, AirFlow, Aruba and Trapeze came out with innovative approaches to fully meshing WLAN coverage.

One could even argue that this re-purposed innovation is superior in many ways to invention. Invention generally takes a wholesale swap-out and generates technology wars. We don't need to return to the early 1990s with transport protocol battles between frame relay, ATM and Switched Multimegabit Data Service. It's preferable in today's economy for companies to have better ways to do core processes using an existing or almost-existing infrastructure.

Economics and innovation must work hand-in-hand. While innovation is usually viewed as good, it will only be meaningful today if it also has a strong business case to support it. Having a good business case can even change "bad" innovation to "good" innovation.

Skype is a case in point. To many IT administrators, the fact that Skype's founders also invented KaZaa overshadowed any possible benefits that peer-to-peer communications could have in the business environment. However, Skype's excellent voice quality and ease of use started softening this attitude. The introduction of gateway services to the public switched telephone network, providing international calls to many locations for about 2 cents per minute, might make this innovative technology even more acceptable.

The bottom line, then, is that innovation is alive and well, albeit in some less-radical forms than in years past. But for this innovation to be taken seriously in today's environment, there's an even stronger imperative that the innovation also have a strong business value.

Read more about voip & convergence in Network World's VoIP & Convergence section.