Skip Links

Network World

  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Close

Certified e-mail is a 'tax'? ... Balderdash!

'Net Buzz By Paul McNamara , Network World , 03/06/2006
McNamara

Any time liberal and conservative activists join forces to confront a corporate behemoth for committing crimes against the Internet, you can be fairly confident the protesters have a legitimate beef ... except when they're completely out to lunch.

Such is the case with last week's pointless caterwauling against plans by AOL to offer Goodmail's CertifiedEmail, a premium delivery service designed to help legitimate bulk senders get their messages through to their intended targets. Fronted by the Electronic Frontier Foundation, MoveOn.org and RightMarch.com, a diverse coalition of 70 organizations has launched a noisy crusade to convince AOL to abandon the plan.

AOL's response in a nutshell: Nuts to you. . . . Good for AOL.

 


What do you think? Discuss in Buzzblog.

Here's an excerpt from the coalition's open letter under the headline "Stop AOL's E-mail Tax": "We wish to express our serious concern with AOL's adoption of Goodmail's CertifiedEmail, which is a threat to the free and open Internet. This system would create a two-tiered Internet in which affluent mass e-mailers could pay AOL a fee that amounts to an 'e-mail tax' for every e-mail sent, in return for a guarantee that such messages would bypass spam filters and go directly to AOL members' in-boxes. Those who did not pay the 'e-mail tax' would increasingly be left behind with unreliable service."

Calling certified e-mail a tax is an excellent example of the intellectually dishonest rhetoric that pollutes so much of public discourse these days. No one has to pay AOL a nickel if they're not interested in the premium service and their e-mail will continue to be treated exactly as it is today. . . . Try telling the IRS you're just not interested.

As for second-class bulk mailers "being left behind with unreliable service," that will happen only if AOL executives decide they really don't want to be in the e-mail business anymore. Suggestions that the company will let standard service wither to prod customers over to certified e-mail ignore the simple reality that AOL has competitors.

Fearing that perhaps I was missing an element of merit in the coalition's complaint, I turned to Paul Hoffman, long active in IETF affairs and director of the VPN Consortium.

The certified e-mail service "is rope that AOL . . . can hang themselves with," Hoffman says, "but who cares?" Of those who object to premium e-mail services, he adds: "Of course they object; they don't want anything to cost them any money. Well, neither do the people who send spam."

Partner Content
CA logo

CA Network & Voice Resource Center

Comprehensive Network & Voice Management Visit CA Network & Voice Management Resource Center and get insights into industry best practices, information that helps you to address your challenges.

CA Network & Voice Management Resource Center

whitepaper

Managing Voice Over IP for Successful Convergence

Voice over IP (VoIP) has much to offer in cost savings but some customers have concerns about VoIP call quality compared to the quality of traditional voice services. This white paper will help you learn how to take the right steps so that voice quality is assured.

Managing VoIP for Successful Convergence

whitepaper

The Changing Face of Network Management

Managing your network is serious business. This paper discusses the benefits of integrating configuration change-awareness into your network fault management solution

Download Whitepaper

Comment
Login
Forgot your account info?
Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to moderator approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.

Videos

rssRss Feed
Save The Date!
What They Are Saying

what are the benefits of project management - Anonymous

Join the Discussion