Don't trust your network to open source
Two industry experts debate the wisdom of choosing open source software over commercial products
Face-off
By Roger Greene, Ipswitch
,
Network World
, 03/05/2007
- Share/Email
- Tweet This
- Print
The basic premise behind open source is simple: When programmers can read, redistribute and modify the source code for software,
the software evolves. In theory, open source sounds like an IT dream -- and in some instances it is. However, in the commercial
marketplace, where your network is the lifeblood of your enterprise, and predictability and profitability are vital, open
source is often unpredictable -- and that can keep your IT staff up at night.
There are three common myths about open source:
* Open source is free. As we all know, there is no such thing as a free lunch. Obtaining open source code from the Internet and then molding it
to fit your environment often is not a good use of your time. If you obtain open source code from a vendor, you can be sure
that you'll pay hefty service fees for customization -- otherwise, how could the vendor stay in business? I'd rather pay an
upfront fee for software that does what I need and doesn't have any high-cost labor attached to it.
Face-off:You can trust your network to open source
* Bug fixes are faster and less expensive in an open source environment. The open source community claims bugs can be fixed faster for open source software than commercial software because hundreds,
if not thousands, of people are looking at the code daily and can help with fixes. The problem is that, contrary to popular
perception, those thousands of developers aren't sitting at home contributing labor for free. Most of them are employed by
Sun, IBM and other large companies to work on the specific open source products that mesh with their strategic interests -- which
are usually large enterprise applications. Even when those individuals generously offer their time for free, can you really afford to wait for one to agree with you
on the urgency of action if your network is down?
Partner Content
Blue Stripe Software
www.bluestripe.com/
Improving Application Performance Troubleshooting
Diagnosing why an application is slow is hard, at times taking days or weeks to isolate and resolve. This paper explains the challenges involved using current management tools, provides a 'wish list' for application management and analysis, and explains the need for an application system-wide approach that monitors entire applications, not components.
Download Whitepaper
Virtual Vigilance: Managing Application Performance in Virtual Environments
This paper highlights the impact of virtualization on application performance. "Managing Application Performance in Virtual Environments" states: "Best-in-Class organizations are predominately taking actions around improving visibility across both physical and virtual systems, assessing the business impact of application performance and understanding interdependencies of applications in virtualized environments."
Download Whitepaper
Application Service Requests: The Missing Link for Pragmatic ITSM
Forrester Research analyst Glenn O'Donnell and BlueStripe co-founder Vic Nyman discuss a breakthrough approach to application problem management. Learn the new approach for ITSM problem management, which provides: Rapid isolation of application slow-downs to specific components for quick problem resolution, 24/7 monitoring for proactive notification of potential issues before end users are impacted and much more.
Register for Webcast
Comments (19)
Face-off: Open source and your networkBy NetworkWorld Community on March 2, 2007, 2:27 pmTwo industry experts debate the wisdom of choosing open source software over commercial network applications: You can trust your network to open source - by Tarus...
Reply | Read entire comment
Roger Greene == Builder of Straw Men (Logical Fallacy)By Decade on March 5, 2007, 6:31 pmAt first, I thought Greene's argument against open source was ludicrous, to the degree that the second point against open source actually was an argument for open...
Reply | Read entire comment
Time to face it: the Internet runs on Open Source SoftwareBy Chuck Talk on March 5, 2007, 10:17 pmI'd really like to remind people of the obvious. Open Source software powers most of the Internet. Apache accounts for nearly 70% of the web, Amazon runs atop Open...
Reply | Read entire comment
In a Split Decision, OSS Wins!By Anonymous on March 6, 2007, 5:53 pmWhile Mr. Balog's example of the four-hour fix may be real, it is also be an anomaly. Not all bugs are squashed as readily nor as quickly in the OS world, and management...
Reply | Read entire comment
I guess if IPSwitch, I'd be trying to keep my company viable.By Paul Misner on March 8, 2007, 3:36 pmIt's funny, there is so much irony with this whole debate. IPSwitch started out as a shareware company. Remember WS-FTP Lite? Filezilla and other free ftp clients...
Reply | Read entire comment
Joe Barr rips Roger Greene a new oneBy Corey on March 9, 2007, 5:00 pmJoe Barr commented on this article.. a good read. http://www.linux.com/article.pl?sid=07/03/09/2035252
Reply | Read entire comment
View all comments