- Microsoft Windows chief decries standards grandstanding
- The 5 best, and 5 worst, features of Google Chrome OS
- Federal government using PS3 to crack pedophile passwords
- 10G Ethernet cheat sheet
- Top 10 free Windows tools for IT pros, at a glance
Blazing headlines warning that American business will lose a billion or more dollars because of the college basketball playoffs have become a ritual of spring. Now such sports-related doom-saying is creeping into the fall. I just saw a headline that claimed fantasy football was going to cost American businesses $435 million per week during the upcoming NFL season. The basic premise that this kind of money is actually lost is more than a bit wacko, and this should be clear to just about everyone, so why do these fantasy numbers get so widely reported? (See "20 amazing, amusing and alarming IT 'facts'".)
Every spring for a number of years the news media has gone all a-twitter over the idea that the productivity of U.S. businesses
will tank during the college basketball playoffs (called March Madness by sports reporters). Last year the cost was estimated
to be $1.7 billion. In the same vein, big employee productivity losses were forecasted due to distractions caused by the latest
Super Bowl. Most recently came headlines on Fox Business news and elsewhere that employees playing fantasy football would waste hundreds of millions of their employers’
dollars every month. The Fox story quoted the source of most of these dubious statistics as saying, "The potential damage
to morale and loyalty resulting from a fantasy football ban could be far worse than the loss of productivity caused by 10
minutes of online team management." Oh, this sounds real bad --
maybe businesses should band together to shut down American football in order to protect themselves from the inattention of
their own employees.
Another big deal with March Madness, or so it was claimed, was the impact on the corporate data network of all those employees watching streaming video of the games that were played during business hours. Clearly the answer to that is to get the NCAA to stop playing games during the business day.
All of these estimates of risk to businesses seem to ultimately come from the same source: the outplacement firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas. Putting out this sort of big-number impact prediction certainly has had what I assume was the desired result -- lots of free press coverage of the firm so that employers might remember "the original outplacement company" (as its Web page puts it) when it comes time to do some outplacement. But anyone actually looking at the numbers has to admit that the conclusions drawn are speculative, at best.
Comment