Same mobile router, different approaches
Verizon's MiFi 2200 is also faster (at least in New England)
Cool Tools
By
Keith Shaw
,
Network World
, 06/23/2009
- Share/Email
- Tweet This
- Print
The scoop: MiFi 2200 Intelligent Mobile Hotspot, by Verizon Wireless, about $100 (after rebates, two-year-agreement, plus data service,
at $40 per month for 250MB of data, or $60 per month for 5GB of data).
What it is: About the size of a credit-card (but slightly thicker too), the MiFi 2200 from Verizon Wireless includes a 3G wireless connection
(Verizon's EV-DO Rev. A network) and a Wi-Fi router built into it. Mobile users can connect to the device via Wi-Fi or USB
and access the Internet through the 3G wireless connection. Multiple users can connect via Wi-Fi and share the data connection.
The device includes a rechargeable battery, which means you can operate it without plugging it into an outlet, although one
is provided. You can also power and use the device via USB cable.
Why it's cool: Does this device sound familiar to you? It should, as Sprint has the same device – Novatel Wireless makes the basic device,
and then each carrier adds its own imprint. The difference then becomes the carrier's network connection, and additional software,
features, functions, etc.
So what's different? The biggest surprise was seeing how each carrier approached the functions of the device. On the Verizon
device, the main goal is for mobile workers to use the device as a USB 3G wireless modem (it installs the VZAccess Manager
software on your PC and then treats the device as a 3G modem, just as if you were using a PC Card or USB stick). The Sprint version assumes you're going to connect to the MiFi via Wi-Fi, so it doesn't install any software on the machine – configuration
is done through a Web browser. You can also configure the Verizon device through a browser (for adjusting the Wi-Fi settings,
changing security, doing port forwarding, etc.), but the main purpose, again, from Verizon's perspective, seems to be to use the device as a 3G wireless access device, with the Wi-Fi a secondary function. I preferred,
slightly, the Verizon method of installation/configuration via the USB cable, as it meant less time digging through the manuals
looking for passwords and such.
One big difference was access speed to the 3G wireless networks – I tested the Verizon Wireless device on a road trip from
Boston to New York, and was able to get more than 1Mbps of download speed and about 380Kbps of upload speed on average during
the trip (average for the Sprint device was about 428Kbps download and 232Kbps upload). I had good EV-DO Rev. A coverage during
most of my trip on Verizon's network.
Comment