Skip Links

Network World

  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Close

(Comma separation for multiple addresses)
Your Message:

Irrational rights

Backspin By Mark Gibbs , Network World , 07/02/2009
Gibbs
  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print

Happy July Fourth! This is the day we celebrate the United States declaring itself free from the tyranny of British rule and that "all men are created equal" and have "unalienable rights."

All good stuff to be sure, but it seems that while we strive to ensure the equality of all men (and women), the citizens of this country are not the only ones with rights. Nope, there are big corporations that are zealously defending their rights and they appear to be treated as more equal under the law.

The latest example of this was the award early last month of -- I am not kidding -- $1,920,000 against a single mother of four children for downloading 24 songs some two years ago using the Kazaa network. Let me put that in perspective: It works out to $80,000 per track! That better be the best music ever recorded.

Now, it is true that the perp, one Jammie Thomas-Rasset, was indeed as guilty as they come. She didn't download just 24 tracks, she downloaded 1,702 tracks. But the prosecution, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), chose to focus on just 24 of them.

Worse still, Thomas also lied under oath to the court. She blamed the downloading on her ex-boyfriend, then her kids (how warped is that?), and tried to destroy the evidence by getting her hard drive replaced and then lied about that. She was, shall we say, not playing with a full deck. Indeed, she had a losing hand.

But what amazes me is the size of the award. The amount is actually based on statutory damages, which is to say that it is set in the laws under which the case was brought, which if you're interested is TITLE 17-COPYRIGHTS, CHAPTER 5, § 504.

This subsection specifies that the damages should be "not less than $750 … [and] where the copyright owner sustains the burden of proving, and the court finds, that infringement was committed willfully, the court in its discretion may increase the award of statutory damages to a sum of not more than $150,000." In other words, Thomas could have theoretically been penalized to the tune (pun intended) of $3,600,000!

But when you can buy a song from iTunes for $0.99, doesn't a value inflation of just over 80,000% seem, shall we say, somewhat excessive?

It has been suggested that the jury was angered when it was established that Thomas was lying her head off and thus decided to go medieval on her. Even so, a fine she could have conceivably paid, $18,000 at the lowest level, would have been far more effective.

  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print
Partner Content

Gartner 2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling

Gartner has positioned BMC CONTROL-M in the Leaders Quadrant of their "2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling." The report assesses the ability to execute and completeness of vision of key vendors in the marketplace. Read a full copy today, courtesy of BMC Software.

Download whitepaper

Dell's SMART Approach to Workload Automation

Read a compelling case study by EMA, Inc. to learn how Dell uses BMC CONTROL-M to cut cost and increase productivity with workload automation.

Download whitepaper

Workload Automation Cost Savings 2 Minute Video

A major computer manufacturer uses BMC CONTROL-M and just four people to schedule and run over 85,000 jobs every month. By switching to BMC CONTROL-M, they more than quadrupled the workload without adding a single staff member.  See how in this 2-minute video overview.

Go to video

Comments (4)
Login
Forgot your account info?

How was she caught?By Allan on July 2, 2009, 1:36 pmI agree that the settlement is a little out there. What I want to know is how she was targeted. Why her out of the possible pool of file sharing users in the US...

Reply | Read entire comment

Losing battleBy corvettekenny on July 2, 2009, 4:33 pmThe intellectual/nontangible property rights battle has been raging for over a decade, and the RIAA and MPAA still haven't figured it out. Suing people for money...

Reply | Read entire comment

Coverup vs crimeBy Anonymous on July 7, 2009, 1:04 pmLooks like the coverup was way worse than the crime - had she fessed up I'm guessing that she could have avoided the 6-figure judgement. Was it also aleged that...

Reply | Read entire comment

Not excessiveBy Anonymous on July 7, 2009, 1:33 pmIf she downloaded 1,702 tracks and seeded them, it could easily have amounted to more than 80,000 downloads per track. She got off easy with only 24 tracks against...

Reply | Read entire comment

View all comments

Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.

Videos

rssRss Feed
Partner Content

Gartner 2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling

Gartner has positioned BMC CONTROL-M in the Leaders Quadrant of their "2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling." The report assesses the ability to execute and completeness of vision of key vendors in the marketplace. Read a full copy today, courtesy of BMC Software.

Download whitepaper

Dell's SMART Approach to Workload Automation

Read a compelling case study by EMA, Inc. to learn how Dell uses BMC CONTROL-M to cut cost and increase productivity with workload automation.

Download whitepaper

Workload Automation Cost Savings 2 Minute Video

A major computer manufacturer uses BMC CONTROL-M and just four people to schedule and run over 85,000 jobs every month. By switching to BMC CONTROL-M, they more than quadrupled the workload without adding a single staff member.  See how in this 2-minute video overview.

Go to video