Skip Links

Network World

Paul McNamara

Early returns on voting machines

By Paul McNamara on Tue, 11/07/06 - 10:15am.

You can count on reading these stories all day today, but here is the first batch of reports on how the electronic voting machines are faring … with a balky Web site thrown in for variety.

Quote of the day: “We got five machines — one of them's got to work," said Willette Scullank, a trouble shooter from the Cuyahoga County, Ohio, elections board.”

Moments ago this post was listed first on Google News among some 434 online articles about electronic voting. Needless to say, that’s a good thing in terms of generating traffic. … Then news broke that Britney Spears is divorcing what’s-his-name. … Election? What election?

We’ll soldier on figuring that a few of you still care.

A call to you lawyers out there: Is there any chance this fellow can claim self-defense? From the AP: “A man was arrested at a polling site Tuesday after election workers said he smashed an electronic voting machine with a paperweight, police said. Michael Young, 43, of Allentown, will face charges of felony criminal mischief and tampering with voting machines, Assistant Police Chief Ronald Manescu said. … "He came in here very peaceably and showed his ID, then he got on the machine and just snapped," volunteer Gladys Pezoldt told The Morning Call of Allentown. On the other hand, even this layman is pretty sure that poll workers are forbidden by law from choking would-be voters. But again, lawyers, correct me if I’m wrong.Things got off to a rocky start in Ohio – needless to say – but appear to be getting better.   From the Cleveland Plain Dealer: “As of 12:30 p.m. all polling places in Cuyahoga County were using electronic voting machines, a Board of Elections spokesman said. However, it’s not clear whether all machines are working at every polling place. … This morning, more than 40 polling places in Cuyahoga County reported problems when the polls opened.”In Denver, you just don’t want to be an IT professional involved in running this election: From the Denver Post: “Democratic party leaders are planning to seek a two-hour extension for voting in Denver, due to massive computer problems which have created long lines, and kept many from casting their vote. Party spokesman Brian Mason said a motion is being prepared, in response to ‘the huge problems in Denver this morning.’ ”  

Maybe there are reports out there of these screw-ups benefiting Democratic candidates at the expense of their Republican opponents, but I just don’t come across them. From TPM Café: “My wife just came home from voting here in Webster Groves MO. She used the electronic touch-screen voting system. . . She touched Claire McCaskill's picture and the machine recorded a vote for Jim Talent. She then called one of the people running the polling center who helped her correct the problem. My wife then had to call the person over another time after it recorded her vote a Republican again. In her frustration she asked the person who was responsible for the design of this system. The polling person leaned in very close to my wife and whispered, 'We're f----d.' "

No liberal conspiracy, this distaste for electronic voting machines. Why Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman and conservative commentator Bob Novak have been caught with their hands inside the paper-ballot box … despite having the option to e-vote, according to Talking Points Memo.

At the risk of appearing to be fair, it’s worth noting that optical scanning equipment didn’t do much better at one Ohio polling place, where a member of Congress attempting to vote for herself (presumably) was both thwarted and filmed.

The Daily Advertiser in Louisiana leaves no malfunctioning voting machine unturned: “A mechanic is on the way to the former St. Antoine Elementary School to check on a voting machine that is reportedly malfunctioning, said Lafayette Parish Clerk of Court Louis Perret.” … We’ll be sure to keep an eye on the situation at St. Antoine Elementary School.From the AP: “WASHINGTON — Voting machines began wreaking havoc the minute the polls opened Tuesday, delaying voters in dozens of Indiana and Ohio precincts and leaving some in Florida with little choice but turn to paper ballots instead.”From The CourierPost in New Jersey: About 30 of Camden County's 700 voting machines have experienced problems today, according to Phyllis Pearl, superintendent of elections.”

From Pittsburgh.com: “A few hours after the polls opened, there were problems reported with electronic voting machines.”

From CBS4.com in Florida: “Voters are urged to cast their ballots carefully as scattered reports of election machine glitches have been reported around South Florida during early voting. CBS4’s Dave Malkoff spoke to early voter, John Mabe who claims when he cast his vote at the Lemon City library early voting facility for Jim Davis, the machine registered Charlie Crist as the correct vote.”From The State in South Carolina: “The first known technology glitch in today’s election has occurred, and that in the state office responsible for overseeing the election. The S.C. Election Commission’s Web site, www.scvotes.org, went down shortly before 8:30 a.m.”

From LancasterOnline in Pa.: “Voters at several polls around Lancaster County have reported issues using electronic touch-screen voting machines. Reports from Lancaster’s 9th Ward, fourth precinct; 2nd Ward, first and second precincts; 6th Ward, first precinct; 8th Ward, eighth and ninth precinct; and Manheim Township’s 7th district had reports of malfunctioning machines and/or voter confusion about how to use the electronic machines.”

Update from NBC in Columbus, Ohio: Even efforts to address the problem are causing problems … “A flood of election-related calls knocked out the phone system serving Franklin County offices on Tuesday morning. County Elections Director Matthew Damschroder said the phone lines were overwhelmed by voters wondering where to vote and poll workers needing help with electronic voting machines.”

Another update: From Central Florida News 13: Seems that spring ahead/fall back stuff was too tricky for some of the machines. “Glitches are showing up on touch screen voting machines in Volusia and other counties around Central Florida. The Volusia Supervisor of Elections says the problems started showing up when the automatic clock inside the machines did not reset to make up for Daylight Saving Time.”

One more: They’re voting in California now, which, of course, means that the machines are balking there, too. From SignOnSanDiego.com: “Computerized voting machines in several parts of the county weren't working early Tuesday morning and voters were forced to use paper ballots instead. But a county spokesman said there had been no reports of widespread problems with the machines. Voting machine glitches were reported in Birdland, City Heights, South Park, La Mesa and National City.” 

Can’t call this one a “glitch:” From WMC TV in Memphis comes news of a major snafu where the Democratic candidate for U.S. Senate has already filed a challenge: With Tennessee voters going to the polls, Harold Ford Jr. claimed this morning that polling locations in Memphis and in Jackson shut down because their voting machines weren't working. 'They told all the polling workers to go home and the election officials to go home without giving any real guidance to voters. We've already leveled one (challenge) on behalf of voters who have been told they'd have to wait until later today to vote,' Ford said."

More trouble out West, this one steaming those who like to vote before getting to work. From The Daily Herald in Utah: “Encoder problems at most, if not all, of the 118 voting stations left early morning voters standing in line for more than an hour waiting to cast their electronic ballots. There were problems with the encoders at most, if not all, of the polls in Utah County, said Sandy Hoffmann, elections coordinator for Utah County, but all of the problems have been remedied.”

This one seems to qualify as an exception to the rule in that it cites only a single problem. From the Roanoke Times in Virginia: “Turnout in today’s election was steady in the Roanoke and New River valleys, with at least one voting machine glitch causing a slight backup.”

In South Carolina the problems are causing bad-hair days. From MyrtleBeach.com: “Sandy Martin, Voters Registration & Election director for Horry County, said she felt like pulling her hair out because of the chaos of Tuesday morning. I don't have a lot of hair, and I don't need to be pulling it out," said Martin of her blond-brown locks. "It's been chaotic. It's been a hectic morning."

 

Tags

It's not just the newfangled touchscreen devices

0

Boston uses optical-scan ballots, i.e., you fill out something like a standardized test form, then feed it into a reader (cool because, in case something goes wrong, there's still a paper ballot to count, basically). Here's an account from one polling station where the reader refused to work.

Thanks

0

...for the conpilation of different sources. Perhaps this is the year that elections are settled by lawyers. I am tired of watching Democrats merely concede after these mysterious problems through their victory away.

Reply

0

AMEN !

It's their fault then...

0

I am tired of watching Democrats merely concede after these mysterious problems through their victory away.

If they just let it go, then it's their fault that they lost. If they believe that they didn't get a fair shake then it is up to that person to do something about it, and if they don't, it's their own damn fault. I don't get why everyone thinks that suddenly that there is some kind of conspiracy of some sort that the Republicans have created. If there is a race that somehow the long shot underdog (republican) wins, there will be a story with very sketchy facts on how it was somehow rigged.

There are many reasons that the machines fail, bad infrastructure, failed to configure correctly, failure at not having people that know what to do in case of problems, and finally not idiot proofing the machine (I know it's a dream) etc. There are only so many ways to say/show "Press here if you want to vote for ######". If people can't figure that out then your screwed.

I think the whole country

0

I think the whole country needs to use these. I don't care how long it takes to calculate or how many manhours it takes. These electronic machines are just not working. The election worker I talked to today (I live in a small town in Tennessee) said she doesn't even own a computer and she couldn't "figure out these machines if her life depended on it." Luckily we didn't have problems today. But they are being reported all over the state and the workers are not equipped to handle them.

For decades, schools have been using paper scan-tron sheets and having no issues. Why can't we just use those.

One more thing. There's no need for these machines to be touch-screens. This causes problems because the calibration is improperly and sometimes never tested, causing problems all over the country.

Ok. I'm done
Thank you,
-Cliff

After working in customer

0

After working in customer service for 2 years I have to come to the realization that people are just ignorant and usually can not use electronics. Even something as simple as touch screen voting. I don't think anyone is trying to rig the election. The people having problems are just dumb.

I got worse news for you.

0

I got worse news for you. After working in computing for a decade, I've learned that most programmers stink (though only 50% of them are below average). Now if absolutely everything goes right, then in the final moment, voters could still screw it up, particularly if a voting machine is badly designed, which most of them are.

Computer voting systems not completely open for testing and review by disinterested third parties
are about as safe as attempting a moon launch with a Yugo and several tons of C-4.

If you don't have a paper trail backup, like the "fill the bubble" ballots give you, then you are basically just begging for an election to be stolen. If the machines make it easy to steal an election (and they do), then eventually it will happen. And it will happen again and again until we demand change. Of course, we need to vote to make a change, so there is kind of a Catch-22, right?

No reports of screw ups benefitting dems???

0

"Maybe there are reports out there of these screw-ups benefiting Democratic candidates at the expense of their Republican opponents, but I just don’t come across them."

Apparently you're not looking too hard.
Here's one in case you missed it...
http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/story?section=elections&id=4737362
"In New Jersey, voters in at least seven jurisdictions attempting to vote for Kean and found their machines "locked" for Menendez, according to GOP Committee attorney Mark Sheridan, who called it a "disturbing and developing trend" emerging at the polls.

Sheridan said Republicans are trying to figure out if this is a result of computer error or malfeasance on the part of poll workers. He said it would be too much of a coincidence for anything other than "fraud.""

We all should get rid of these stupid machine...

0

We all should get rid of these e-voting machines... It's cost taxs payer too much money to run this machine... And with the e-voting machine the way it is it will cause a lot of election to be thrown away... E-voting machine are not dependable since it's not really hacc proof and there are no paper trail to look bacc on... So I think if America want to get on the right tracc they should get rid of these machines since it's causing a lot of headache for every voters the want to get their votes in... I just read another comment regarding the election in MO where the voters picc a candiate of their choose and the computer will choose the opposite for you... This not right for politician to rigged the machines for their gains... I believe casting votes the old fashion way even if it means lots of man hours to count them... Atleast we have a paper trail too look bacc on and candiate can alwayz request a recount if needed too... With e-voting machines once the damage is done the damage is done their no way of fixing it... I belive you can alwayz manipulate these machines to your advantages... E-Voting Machine = BAD 4 AMERICA!!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Welcome, visitor. Register Log in
About Buzzblog