Windows 8 virus scanners were evaluated for the first time by AV-Test Institute, an independent testing house. Using the vendors' default settings, AV-Test assessed protection, performance and usability categories before certifying 26 home user security products and nine corporate endpoint protection products. The German-based security firm ran its test throughout January and February 2013. Each product was rated with a score from zero to six in the three categories, with a total high score of 18.
Previous evaluations by AV-Test scored security solutions based on protection, repair and usability. Repair was replaced by performance this time, since AV-Test will issue "repair reports" separately to measure how well security solutions can repair Windows 8 systems that are already infected. Unlike the last two AV-Test reports, in which Microsoft Security Essentials for Windows 7 consumer users failed to pass the independent tests, this time Microsoft was awarded AV-TEST certification for Windows 8.
Antivirus solutions for home users
Microsoft's built-in Windows Defender in Windows 8 was used as the baseline that all others were expected to surpass for consumer level tests. It scored 11.5 out of 18. Bitdefender scored a total of 17, six in both protection and usability, and five in performance.
F-Secure, G Data, Bitdefender, Kaspersky, BullGuard and Trend Micro were all ranked with the top score of six regarding protection against brand new and widespread malware infections. Protection against 0-day attacks were up across the board, with the average score going from 92% in the previous test for Windows 7 to 95% for Windows 8. Below are the top 10 home user virus scanners based on protection.
Webroot, Tencent, Bitdefender and BullGuard were ranked the top four regarding performance. This category measures how the programs impact daily computer speed. Below are the top 10 home user products based on performance.
Eight products managed a perfect score of six in the category of usability. Security software usability is ranked by how a computer is impacted in the following four ways: when websites are blocked or the software gives false warnings about a site; when legitimate software is flagged as malware during a system scan; when false warnings are triggered while installing or using legitimate software; and when the security software blocks certain actions while using or installing legitimate software. Below are the top ten home user security solutions based on usability.
Corporate antivirus solutions
Microsoft System Center Endpoint Protection 2010 & 2012 acted as the baseline with a score of 12.5 for testing the nine corporate solutions. Microsoft's solution scored the lowest for protection, but managed a perfect score of six for usability. Fortinet and Symantec were the top solutions with a total score of 16.5 out 18. Webroot was ranked as the third best with a total of 15. F-Secure and Sophos both had a score of 14.5, followed by Kaspersky with 14. Trend Micro had the lowest overall score of 12, coming in below the baseline set by Microsoft's Endpoint Protection.
The best part about these stats are that the tests are conducted by an independent company. AV-Test conducts more than 3,000 individual and comparative tests every year and uses analysis tools based on its own data. "By using analysis tools that it has developed itself, AV-TEST achieves a maximum level of independence when it comes to test samples." The company added, "All analyses are based on AV-TEST's own test samples, which it has established, analyzed and processed and then compiled in one of the world's most comprehensive data collections. These test samples are then selected and processed in accordance with the respective test requirements."
Like this? Here's more posts:
- White Hat Security: Top 10 most insidious web-based attacks and hacking techniques
- Microsoft goes public, talks about Windows Blue and Build 2013 conference
- Hackers steal photos, turn Wi-Fi cameras into remote surveillance device
- Black Hat Europe: 'Hardening Windows 8 Apps for the Windows Store'
- DOJ & SEC allegedly investigating Microsoft over bribery allegations in 3 countries
- Callers chime in on FAA drone privacy meeting
- DOJ, DHS rejecting law school grads based on online comments
- CIA Chief advises you to ask: What are your rights? Who owns your data?
- Microsoft may not scan your email for keywords like Google, but your boss can
- Microsoft: Facebook Home is a copycat, Windows Phone is the 'real thing'
Follow me on Twitter @PrivacyFanatic
Ms. Smith (not her real name) is a freelance writer and programmer with a special and somewhat personal interest in IT privacy and security issues. Smith has a diverse background in information technology, programming, web development, IT consulting, and information security. She focuses on the unique challenges of maintaining privacy and security, both for individuals and enterprises. She has worked as a journalist and has also penned many technical papers and guides covering various technologies. Smith is herself a self-described privacy and security freak.
Smith is an independent contractor and is not affiliated with any vendor that makes or sells information technology.
Policy on comments: Respectful discussion is welcomed! However comments that use inappropriate language, consist of name calling or personal attacks, or include accusations of wrongdoing are not appropriate. Those comments will be deleted or edited