Network World
Tuesday, December 2, 2008
DNSstuff.com
Get information about your IP
IP Information
50+ On-demand DNS and network tools

Community

Navigation

Networking's 50 greatest arguments

Check out our take on the nastiest, most colorful and in some cases, still unresolved network industry arguments. and then jump into the debate! Any we missed? We want to hear from YOU!

A couple of oldies but goodies

Who could forget..

Word vs. Wordperfect
SQL Server vs. Oracle
Apache vs. IIS

You left out one - 100BaseT vs 100VG

Maybe it only seems big to me because I was on the loosing side, But VG was first with 100Mbps products and with round robin access controlled by the switches, VG was deterministic. Unfortunately VG was only half-duplex and lost out in the long run to full duplex switched 100BaseT.

100VG still not first

Actually TCNS (Thomas Conrad Networking System) was 100Mb before 100VG was. :)

But I'm just showing my age at this point... It was an interesting solution, but not really scalable in the grand scheme of things. But hey, when you need fast and that's the only thing around (remember, they were the kings of Arcnet), whaddya do?

Scott

Are you kidding?

IDS vs. IPS?? That is not an argument. These tools are not mutually exclusive but helpful in doing different tasks which should be done in conjuction with each other.
Apache vs. IIS is an argument (and a big one) that was obviously missed, however.

IDS vs IPS and Apache vs. IIS

Think our point here was that at the time IPS emerged, there was a debate about whether to go with that or IDS. As you say, the two have proven to be complementary and merged in some cases.

Excellent point on Apache vs. IIS. I smell a sequel to this story package...have started collecting ideas.

Thanks a lot for writing.

BobB, news editor

How could you forget...

SNMP vs OSI CMIP

I remember this one being pretty interesting, with some colorful folks involved: Jeff "these dogs will hunt" Case, Marshall Rose, and a whole cast of others.

And lest we forget ...

X.12 vs. UN/EDIFACT. As a cub technology reporter back in the day, I was amazed at the politics involved in EDI over these two formats - as in, an American industry group arguing against UN/EDIFACT specifications for defining shipping dates because the UN had defined it, and that was un-American!

MCA vs EISA

MicroChannel vs Extended ISA

CISC vs RISC

Complex instruction set computer vs reduced instruction set computer.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Advertisement: