The Federal Trade Commission said the company that crammed more then 15 million PCs full of spyware have agreed to pay $330,000 in fines and be monitored by federal authorities for up to eight years. The fine, however, will increase to over $3.5 million if the court finds that the companies have misrepresented their financial status, the FTC said.
In November 2006, the FTC charged ERG Ventures, with tricking consumers into downloading malevolent software by hiding its Media Motor program within seemingly innocuous free software, including screensavers and video files. Once downloaded, the Media Motor program silently activated itself and downloaded “malware” that was intrusive, disruptive, and made it difficult for consumers to use their computers.
The software changed consumers’ home pages, tracked their Internet activity, altered browser settings, degraded computer performance, and disabled anti-spyware and anti-virus software. Many of the malware programs installed by the Media Motor program were extremely difficult or impossible for consumers to remove from their computers. The spyware was linked with various companies, including ERG, Joysticksavers.com and Privateinpublic.com.
The FTC charged that ERG Ventures and its principals violated the FTC Act, which bars unfair and deceptive practices. Specifically, the FTC alleged that the defendants failed to disclose to consumers that the free software they offered was bundled with malware.
The agency also charged the defendants with using a deceptive End User License Agreement, which gave consumers the option to halt the installation of all software from ERG Ventures, but secretly installed malware whether consumers accepted or rejected the terms of the agreement. The agency also charged the defendants with unfairly downloading software that causes substantial harm to consumers. At the request of the FTC, the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada froze the defendants’ assets and ordered a halt to their spyware operation pending trial.Whether or not they will pay attention to it, the order permanently bars the defendants from distributing software that interferes with consumers’ computers, including software that tracks consumers’ Internet activity or collects other personal information; generates disruptive pop-up advertising; tampers with or disables other installed programs; or installs other advertising software onto consumers’ computers.
The defendants will also be required to fully disclose the name and function of all software they install on consumers’ computers in the future, and to provide consumers with the option to cancel the installation after viewing the disclosure.
Layer 8 is Network World's daily home for the not-just-networking news.
Contact Layer 8
Layer 8 archive![]()
|
|
FTC zaps spyware scam
$330,000 is laughable given the pain & suffering to which these crooks subjected their victims. The FTC should have gone with the $3.5M fine regardless of what their companies or the 3 individuals are worth -- after all, is the FTC afraid they'll put these crooks out of business???
I couldn't agree more.
I couldn't agree more. Unless they crack down hard on these types of indivduals the problems are only going to get worse. They should have been given prison time as well.
winantispyware?
When will they go after THOSE goons... driveby download and one infected PC.
Laughable indeed
This is less than the TV station got fined for the Janet Jackson Super Bowl nipple slip. Methinks they need to get their priorities straight, FTC does.
Here's the names of the Guilty
Federal Trade Commission, Plaintiff, v. ERG Ventures, LLC and d/b/a ERG Ventures, LLC2, Media Motor, Joysticksavers.com, and PrivateinPublic.com; Elliot S. Cameron, individually and d/b/a ERG Ventures, LLC2, Media Motor, Joysticksavers.com, and PrivateinPublic.com; Robert A. Davidson, II, individually and d/b/a ERG Ventures, LLC2, Media Motor, Joysticksavers.com, and PrivateinPublic.com; Gary E. Hill, individually and d/b/a ERG Ventures, LLC2, Media Motor, Joysticksavers.com, and PrivateinPublic.com, Timothy P. Taylor, individually and d/b/a Team Taylor Made, Defendants.
Old Line:
Eric Qualen: Kill a few people, they call you a murderer. Kill a million and you're a conqueror.
New Line:
Steal a few thousand they call it grand larsony and throw you in jail. Steal a few million and you're a scammer and you only get monitored!
FTC zaps spyware scam
Because ERG Ventures violated so many laws and violated so many people's trust,$330,000 is a mere pittance of a fine; the company officers should be tossed in jail for 8 years, not just monitored.
330 K is a joke.
Look at it this way: If this stuff is hard to remove, a tech's charge to get rid of it would be in the neighborhood of a hundrd bucks. The find should be at least $75.00 per computer. That's 15,000,000 (# of computers infected, per the article) X $75. And the principals of the company should do 5 to 10 years in jail- a state pen, just as if they had broken into people's homes and stolen their money - while the programmers should do 3 to 5.
And yet they are all going to skate.
How could that be? Where's the so called "Justice" Department?
The FTC is bereft of
The FTC is bereft of prosecutorial ardor. Not only is $330K paltry, these administrative fines are seldom collected.
The message from the FTC to the criminals is to go ahead and scam consumers, but if you get caught you might be asked to share a fraction of the ill-gotten gains.