Network World
Sunday, July 20, 2008
DNSstuff.com
Get information about your IP
IP Information
50+ On-demand DNS and network tools

Nearpoints

Web Tablets: This Year's Model

Every few years I purchase a new "Web tablet" device for personal use. This is not yet a recognized category of product (although some call it an "Internet tablet"), so let me define it first. A Web tablet is a device that fits between the smartphone and notebook form factors - it's larger than the former and won't fit in most pockets (although it would in many purses), but smaller than the latter and isn't (usually, anyway; see below) running Windows. It's designed first and foremost for quick-and-not-at-all-dirty Web and e-mail access, and many of these have also attracted a good deal of attention from the LINUX community as well for all kinds of applications as well as general use. Pricing is typically in the US$300-$400 range.

My first foray into this space was via the groundbreaking Nokia 770 about three years ago. The 770 is now woefully out of date, but updated and otherwise new software for it (and the others in the family; see below) remains available at the Nokia developer site, Maemo.org. I saw only marginal value in upgrading to the Nokia N800, but the much-improved N810 was definitely on the list for this year's model. This unit has a slide-out keyboard, a design now used on many cell phones, and a much-improved browser. The physical keyboard is a requirement for me, as are a memory-card slot and a removable battery. The iPhone thus did not make the cut - a fine product for many, but not for me. The screen is too small regardless.

I also looked at the Palm TX and the Apple iPod Touch. Neither of these have browsers that are really as capable, as, say, Firefox, and clearly have primary applications of personal organization and personal entertainment, respectively. And I have to say that I've become much more interested in LINUX in recent months, and decided that a LINUX platform would ultimately serve me best. For example, I want to be able to use this device for VNC and other functions - in short, much as I'd use a notebook, but smaller, and not running Windows, but with similar capabilities. The availability of the OpenOffice.org package is a plus, although I'm not anticipating using it a lot at present. It's just nice to know it's there if I need it. And, since I don't need something that I can fit in my pocket, a larger screen and keyboard were key drivers. So, a micro-notebook form factor it is.

(Drum roll here) So, I went with the Asus Eee PC, the 4GB Surf model without the camera. But a few words about the runner up, the Everex Cloudbook - pretty much the same thing, but it has a 30 GB hard drive (which I didn't want, as I'm a Web services/network guy) and was $50 more. Also, at the time, it was only available at Walmart.com, and I had a philosophical problem with buy a high-tech product from them. Laundry bins, sure. Computers? No, at least for now. Anyway, my initial reaction to the Eee is more than positive and I'm going to spend a day configuring and exploring it shortly.

In the meantime, there's a lot of good information available at eeeuser.com. And, BTW, I bought mine at Newegg.com, which is now the source of most of the products I buy. Good prices, excellent service, and no complaints from me. And, as I hinted above, the Eee will run Windows XP, but why bother?

Anyway, that's enough for now, but I plan in the near future on getting the Eee to work with the USB connection on my Motorola Q to have a go-most-places, big-screen e-mail/Web system that works when there's no Wi-Fi available. I plan on giving presentations via the VGA port. And, who knows, this Web tablet just might replace my notebooks in the majority of applications I need a mobile computer for.

Web Tablets This Years Model Article

Useful answer?
0

In your article you say the following:
The much-improved N810 was definitely on the list for this year's model. This unit has a slide-out keyboard,and a much-improved browser.You also looked at the Apple iPod Touch. the browser is really not as capable, as, say, Firefox.
-------------------------------

I own both and the n810 and the itouch. The n810 is nice for some things but when it comes to browsing the Web and reading articles on web pages the Touch is clearly so much better that it is not even a contest. The pinching and pulling on the itouch makes the page easy to size and position and the touch scrolling is much smoother and nicer.

User Interface Makes a Big Difference...

Useful answer?
0

I agree with you there. Now if Apple only made one with a bigger screen (but at the same price, of course)...

 

Thx. Craig.

The Nokia N800 can be a bargain

Useful answer?
0

Although I am a long-time Mac user, I can appreciate technology from other companies. In that regard, Nokia is a leader.

Recently I purchased a Nokia N800, passing by the iPhone and iPod Touch.

Unlike the Apple products, the N8XX series is open, with plenty of available and free applications. (Even the back of my N800 can be opened, to replace the battery. Something that can't be done with the iPhone or Touch.)

So why the N800 and not the N810? Price. Although the N800 has a mechanical keyboard and GPS (but only one SD slot instead of the two on the N800), I was able to buy the N800 on one of the recent periodic sales on the web for less than $200, delivered.

The N810 costs over twice that. It wasn't worth another $200+ to get the keyboard and GPS.

It is worth remembering that, under the skin, both the N800 and N810 are identical. Both can have OS2008 installed on them.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

About Craig Mathias

Mathias is a principal at Farpoint Group, a wireless advisory firm in Ashland, Mass.

RSS feed

Craig Mathias's archive.

Wireless Research Center.

Advertisement: