Skip Links

Network World

Brad Reese

Cisco loses $2M order to ruthless Nortel energy efficiency calculator

By Brad Reese on Thu, 05/01/08 - 8:21am.

Signage on display at the Nortel Interop booth in Las Vegas this week:

Calculate Your Cisco Energy Tax Now

Estimate your potential savings by not paying the:

Cisco Energy Tax

The ruthless Nortel energy efficiency calculator continues to take its toll on Cisco according to the most recent TMCnet Hyperconnected Enterprise blog entry:

Tony Rybczynski"I’m here at Interop and customers are getting the facts (verified by independent third parties) on Green networking (50% less energy consumption), on performance (20x better), on reliability (7x the resilience) and on TCO (50% reduction) of our networking solutions," blogs Nortel Enterprise Director - Tony Rybczynski.

"One customer (a School District) stopped processing an order for $2M of Cisco gear when they heard this story!"

"The bottom-line is that enterprises need to do due diligence and look at alternatives to Cisco in the data space. That’s exactly what this School Board is doing."

Related story:

Cisco: When it comes to energy efficiency, there is no one magic metric to measure goodness


Do YOU believe Cisco will continue to lose orders to the ruthless Nortel energy efficiency calculator?

Contact Brad Reese
http://www.BradReese.Com

Search 31,427 Cisco Job Openings

Post Cisco Network Engineer Jobs

View 1,595 items of Refurbished Cisco

Examine CCIE Resumes

Consider 697 Cisco Certified
Network Engineer Resumes

  
Brad's Top 5 Story Picks
# 1. VoIP monitoring: The quest for call quality ubiquity
# 2. Cisco NetFlow vendor giving away Traffic Analyzer!
# 3. Cisco skills shortage is baloney, expert says
# 4. Q & A with the ex-Cisco star who joined ethernet fabric switching startup, Woven Systems
# 5. Help on the way for SMB telephony reseller margins being squeezed to death by Cisco
Story Archives Brad Reese on Cisco Story Archives

Cisco Jobs

Cisco Repair

Cisco Resumes

Cisco Power Supplies

  

Interesting articles. The

0

Interesting articles. The Cisco power tax is getting more and more attention. Does anybody have 20% increases on their power bills though? Regardless, I'm all for equipment that has lower heat dissapation in watts, but thought I spotted some marketing emblishment done under the guise of making a good thing sound better, which undermines all of the factual information presented.

Factual?

0

Energy is at $117 dollars a barrel and some say it will hit 400...
Maybe you don't pay the energy bill for your enterprise, but someone does and they would like to know why the certification seems to hold more gravity with the product selection folks than cost to operate and keep the real stakeholders' bottom line under control.

Cisco v/s Nortel Power

0

Heat, power, etc... they are indeed factors. But we dumped Cisco becasue of their recently impossible to deal with smartnet rules and outright robbery. We use Adtran and HP now. 1/4 the cost, bulletproof reliability, no support costs, FAST fabrics.
As soon as someone comes up with a switch to compete with the 6500 series, we will completely wash our hands of Cisco.

You CAN be completely rid of those guys

0

Full disclosure up front>
I work for Nortel.
But.
The 8600 can match or surpass what the 6509 does.
All I ask is that you call your local Nortel systems engineer and a discussion them him/her about the 8600.

I will not list the features here to bore you with it. I am very familiar with the box and the newest features of the cards added to release 5.0.

You will not be disapointed.
Good luck ripping that 6509 out, it'll save you about 10 to 40k per unit in energy and HVAC in the next 5 or so years.

3560s OUT.. Next to go are the 6500s..

0

This definitely helped us, when my CIO asked "Why do you want to get rid of Cisco" The fact that I hate smart net, I think my Cisco sales rep is by far scum of the earth and nickel and dimes my company to death. I was finally able to say "John, Nortel can cut our power usage by 70% and save our organization close to $55k the first year", they couldn't get the PO in quick enough. I replaced on my 3560s with Nortel 5520s at half the cost, and cut my maintenence in half. Next to go are the 6509s!

Not Quite the Whole Story

0

In the end accurate and transparent information is the best tool for our customers to make informed decisions. The Nortel position paper mentioned compares switches that are plugged in but not connected to anything with the assertion that the difference in draw is an indicated of overall energy efficiency. This is probably a pretty atypical scenario for our customers--having a switch in their data center not connected to anything. Check out my blog posting with some thoughts on measuring energy efficiency, details on how various switches perform under load and an award Cisco recently received for energy efficiency for Cisco Catalyst fixed switches.

Omar Sultan
SMM - Data Center Switching
Cisco Systems
www.cisco.com/go/dcswitching

Good Point

0

Really Omar?

0

Omar, Tolly clearly shows the Nortel 55XX series outperforms the Cisco 3750 in all aspects This would seem to indicate (in true Cisco fashion) you're driving the Focus but charging me twice as much for the gas (I'm sure this was in small print somewhere)..

So, what happened in the end?

0

This story just says a school system somewhere stopped their order...did they order Nortel instead? This is a pretty incomplete story. I bet they just went back to the Cisco people and found out what the real power would be and compared that to the real power of the Nortel box, and then bought the Cisco anyway because they wanted something that worked.

looks pretty clear to me!!

0

looks pretty clear to me!! The story is saying that the customer stopped the order...which tells me that they found something that is not acceptable about the product...stories don't get published while the customer is talking to Cisco...I bet this story came out when they decided that they had enough of BS from Cisco team and started looking at alternate solutions.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Welcome, visitor. Register Log in
About Brad Reese on Cisco

Brad Reese cofounded BradReese.Com Cisco Refurbished, which enables affordable networks globally by assuring customer satisfaction with guaranteed one year warranties on both Cisco Repair as well as Refurbished Cisco.

Don't be shy, contact Brad Reese online or call him Toll Free:

866-864-0506

International callers may wish to call Brad by dialing:

850-364-4115

Archives
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
Categories
America's Best profile written by Useem regarding Chambers' success
Avian Securities Senior Telecom Research Analyst - Catharine Trebnick
Breakingviews.com correspondent - Robert Cyran
CCIE
Careers
Charlie Giancarlo - Managing Director of Silver Lake Partners and Skype investor
Cisco
Cisco ASR 9000 architecture
Cisco ISR G2 Module Support
Cisco Integrated Services Router Generation 2 (ISR G2) Model Comparison
Cisco Integrated Services Routers Generation 2 Portfolio
Cisco Unified Communications Support for Microsoft Windows 7
Cisco is pushing their ASR 9000 at very competitive prices
Cisco is warning Unified Communications customers about NOT successfully offering support for Microsoft Windows 7
Cisco stock chart for the last 10 years
Cisco technical star Jonathan Rosenberg
Cisco will have no liability for any delay in delivery
Daniel Berg - Skype's CTO
Data Center
Douglas Smith - Cofounder and President of Network Instruments
Expand visibility of NetFlow-dependent NBAD and compliance applications
Father of SIP - Jonathan Rosenberg
GigaStor captures and converts packets in NetFlow data flows
Index Venture partner Danny Rimer
Jonathan Rosenberg - a Cisco Fellow in Cisco's Voice Technology Group
Juniper MX960 lab test results
LANs / WANs
Michael Useem - Professor of Management
Microsoft
NetFlow
NetFlow add-ons
NetFlow overhead can overtax infrastructure
Network Behavior Anomaly Detection (NBAD)
Network Management
Non-NetFlow capable devices are blind to local traffic
Produce NetFlow about any device
Rosenberg is now Skype's Chief Technology Strategist
SMB
Security
Selection committee member for America's Best Leaders
September 2009 vs. October 2009 Worldwide CCIE Count Comparison
Silver Lake Managing Director - Egon Durban
Skills and abilities of Skype CTO Daniel Berg
Skype announced Roseberg jumped ship from Cisco
Skype's Chief Technology Strategist - responsible for Skype's overall architecture and technology strategy
Skype's cofounders Niklas Zennstrom and Janus Friis
Software
The Charlie angle is to keep Dave Roux on track
The new Cisco ISR G2 portfolio is priced as follows
VoIP / Convergence
What are the benefits of GigaStor NetFlow Agent?
What’s new on the Cisco ISR G2 models vs. the old ISR models?
When Cisco used its common stock to buy Linksys and Pure Digital
Windows 7
Windows 7 just not worth an all-out urgent effort by Cisco to support
Wireless / Mobile
eBay CEO - John Donahoe
sFlow
sFlow and NetFlow provides extended visibility
On The Web
Twitter