Skip Links

Network World

Brad Reese

Cisco: When it comes to energy efficiency, there is no one magic metric to measure goodness

By Brad Reese on Wed, 05/07/08 - 6:26pm.

Cisco Data Center Networks Blog

Omar Sultan - Cisco CCIE No. 1284 Routing and Switching in his recent Cisco Data Center blog entry, made an interesting point that certainly adds more controversy to our blog story:

Cisco loses $2M order to ruthless Nortel energy efficiency calculator

Omar SultanNortel asserts their ERS 8610 offers energy savings of 60% over a 6500 equivalent. There is not a lot of detail to the comparison, although there is a footnote that states:

Unless noted, all product comparisons are based on vendor published maximum power ratings.

So this seems a comparison of power supplies, not actual draw.

Core switches compared (two each) for power consumption, cooling requirements, carbon emissions

The salient point is that these power values are for two switches plugged-in and idling with no connections--the assertion is that if there is such a discrepancy at idle, imagine what happens when we actually forward packets.

I guess the moral of the story here is, when it comes to energy efficiency, there is, sadly, no one magic metric to measure goodness. Its a design function like anything else in the data center and its a matter of doing research and balancing the design parameters.

View Omar's entire blog entry.

Omar's point that a comparison at idle, may not accurately measure what happens when packets are forwarded is a good one.


Do YOU agree with Omar that when it comes to energy efficiency, there is no one magic metric to measure goodness?

Contact Brad Reese
http://www.BradReese.Com

Brad's Top 5 Story Picks
# 1. Cisco CEO John Chambers likes to read Network World Magazine
# 2. H-1B scandal: New study unmasks that Cisco and Microsoft NOT using H-1B visas to recruit the best and brightest
# 3. Cisco loses $2M order to ruthless Nortel energy efficiency calculator
# 4. VoIP monitoring: The quest for call quality ubiquity
# 5. Cisco NetFlow vendor giving away Traffic Analyzer!
Story Archives Brad Reese on Cisco Story Archives

Cisco Jobs

Cisco Repair

Cisco Resumes

Cisco Power Supplies

  

there is no one magic metric to measure goodness....

0

But there are lots of ways to measure badness. Typical obsfucation, Omar. When confronted by an inconvenient truth, deflect and dodge, but don't answer the question.

This seems incredibly simple to me. Test the systems under whatever load you prefer and publish the numbers. Then let us compare. Don't tell me to go to your power calculator and plug in 100 different parameters (and oh, by the way, you need a cisco.com account).

And finally, please, please, please stop citing Meircom as an "independent" testing organization. I haven't seen a Meircom test in the last decade that didn't feature a Cisco device winning...

What else will be helpful?

0

Anon111:

It would seem that Cisco has provided what you are looking for: the Meircom report I linked to in my blog provides power draw at idle, 5% uplink load and 100% uplink load. Since I noted that power draw is proportional to switch load, you can approximate draw for your particular environment.

The Power Calculator and DCAP are tools for our customers to determine actual power and cooling load, instead of working from the max draw, which is a level of granularity that our customers find helpful. Yes, you do need to register with Cisco.com to access them--sorry for not mentioning that. Again, the goal is to give customers greater transparency on actual power draw. While the complexity in inherent, we do try and avoid it, but the reality is that a switch pushing 10GbE will have a higher draw than the same switch pushing GE and most customers have told us they are interested in that level of detail.

The original point in my blog was that measuring the draw of an idling switch, the basis of the Nortel claims, was not all that helpful. While I have engaged in much discussion since that blog post, I have yet to have anyone disagree with that point.

That being said, any feedback on metrics you would like to see is always welcome.

Omar Sultan
SMM - Data Center Switching
Cisco Systems
www.cisco.com/go/dcswitching

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Welcome, visitor. Register Log in
About Brad Reese on Cisco

Brad Reese cofounded BradReese.Com Cisco Refurbished, which enables affordable networks globally by assuring customer satisfaction with guaranteed one year warranties on both Cisco Repair as well as Refurbished Cisco.

Don't be shy, contact Brad Reese online or call him Toll Free:

866-864-0506

International callers may wish to call Brad by dialing:

850-364-4115

Archives
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
Categories
A classic scam to defraud Cisco's SMARTnet program
America's Best profile written by Useem regarding Chambers' success
Avian Securities Senior Telecom Research Analyst - Catharine Trebnick
Breakingviews.com correspondent - Robert Cyran
CCIE
Careers
Charlie Giancarlo - Managing Director of Silver Lake Partners and Skype investor
Cisco
Cisco ASR 9000 architecture
Cisco ISR G2 Module Support
Cisco Integrated Services Router Generation 2 (ISR G2) Model Comparison
Cisco Integrated Services Routers Generation 2 Portfolio
Cisco Unified Communications Support for Microsoft Windows 7
Cisco is pushing their ASR 9000 at very competitive prices
Cisco is warning Unified Communications customers about NOT successfully offering support for Microsoft Windows 7
Cisco technical star Jonathan Rosenberg
Cisco will have no liability for any delay in delivery
Data Center
Douglas Smith - Cofounder and President of Network Instruments
Expand visibility of NetFlow-dependent NBAD and compliance applications
GigaStor captures and converts packets in NetFlow data flows
Index Venture partner Danny Rimer
Jonathan Rosenberg - a Cisco Fellow in Cisco's Voice Technology Group
Juniper MX960 lab test results
LANs / WANs
Mark Roberts - Polycom vice president of partner marketing
Michael Useem - Professor of Management
Microsoft
NetFlow
NetFlow add-ons
NetFlow overhead can overtax infrastructure
Network Behavior Anomaly Detection (NBAD)
Network Management
Non-NetFlow capable devices are blind to local traffic
Produce NetFlow about any device
SMB
Security
Selection committee member for America's Best Leaders
September 2009 vs. October 2009 Worldwide CCIE Count Comparison
Silver Lake Managing Director - Egon Durban
Skype's cofounders Niklas Zennstrom and Janus Friis
Software
The Charlie angle is to keep Dave Roux on track
The new Cisco ISR G2 portfolio is priced as follows
VoIP / Convergence
What are the benefits of GigaStor NetFlow Agent?
What’s new on the Cisco ISR G2 models vs. the old ISR models?
Windows 7
Windows 7 just not worth an all-out urgent effort by Cisco to support
Wireless / Mobile
eBay CEO - John Donahoe
sFlow
sFlow and NetFlow provides extended visibility
On The Web
Twitter