Court rules new HP executive vice president is officially AWOL from EMC

This week Boston technology attorney Lee Gesmer blogged in his Mass Law Blog:

What Happens When California and Massachusetts Law on the Enforceability of Non-Compete Agreements Clash in Massachusetts Superior Court? Read on...

According to Gesmer, "California’s legislative policy against non-compete agreements does not trump Massachusetts common law, at least under the facts of this case."

Last week, after being paid $17.2 million over the last 3 years of his employment as President of the EMC Storage Division, David Donatelli sued his former employer EMC in California state court seeking to void his non-compete agreement so that he could become the new Executive Vice President of HP's Enterprise Servers, Storage and Networking division. Naturally, after Donatelli filed his California lawsuit, EMC countersued in Massachusetts state court seeking to have Donatelli's non-compete agreement enforced.

The result?

Donatelli lost even though he hired famed Boston employment lawyer superstar Jay Shepherd to represent him in front of Judge Stephen Neel of the Massachusetts Suffolk County Superior Court in Boston.

Gesmer also noted in his blog, "The agreement recited that it had been signed UNDER SEAL, magic words that favor enforceability in Massachusetts."

An HP spokesperson responded to yours truly with regard to EMC's court victory, "We are disappointed that the Massachusetts court saw fit to delay Mr. Donatelli’s employment with HP. However, the court’s order is preliminary, and we are confident that Mr. Donatelli will be permitted to join HP in a leadership role once a full hearing of the issues is held. We are similarly disappointed by the lengths to which EMC has gone to impede Mr. Donatelli’s efforts to seek other employment."

Simultaneously, EMC continued to remain very tight-lipped and this was the most that I was able to pry loose from an EMC spokesperson, "EMC is aware of the court's decision."

The 15 page court decision is a fascinating document to read and I highly recommend it.

Interestingly, on May 13, 2002, Donatelli signed an EMC Key Employee Agreement which states:

"For the twelve month period following the effective date of your termination, for any reason, from the Company, you agree not to directly or indirectly compete with the Company...[including] (i) the provision of any services...as an employee...to any entity that is developing, producing, marketing, soliciting or selling products or services competitive with product or services being developed, produced, marketed or sold by the Company as of the affective day of your termination."

View the entire 15 page EMC vs. Donatelli Decision below:

Related stories:

Judge calls bluff made by HP's new networking boss!

New HP Networking boss took $17.2M from EMC, but sues to void his non-compete agreement

What's your take, is Donatelli AWOL from EMC or just a simple no show at HP?

BradReese.Com Cisco Refurbished - Services that protect, maintain and optimize Cisco hardware
Contact: Brad Reese | Twitter: http://twitter.com/BradReese

1. Cinco de Mayo: Cisco loses $45M telepresence deal to Polycom
2. Cash in on lower Cisco gross margins this week
3. Juniper Networks takes direct aim at Cisco's one million certified engineers
4. New HP Networking boss took $17.2M from EMC, but sues to void his non-compete agreement
5. 100% trade-in credit for Nortel products
6. Is former Cisco star Mike Volpi selling his dilly-dallier of a video service Joost?
7. Overcoming fear, uncertainty and doubt (FUD) in the secondary Cisco market
8. Cisco sales pipeline is thawing
9. How can we help Cisco's partner talent portal avoid failure?
10. Cisco against Buy America provisions of the $7.2B broadband stimulus fund
11. Cisco may be experiencing some near-term delays with its MDS storage switch refresh
12. Cisco phone inadvertently featured onboard Air Force One
13. Cisco has replaced Intel for second place status on The Mercury News Silicon Valley 150
14. Visual networking meets 2 new visualizations of Cisco NetFlow data
15. Juniper Networks missed its quarter for the first time in a long time
16. Cisco target of 20 patent troll lawsuits
17. Cisco.com domain name about to expire soon
18. Wall Street analyst Mark Sue discusses the long term evolution (LTE) trends at the core
19. Mitch Barrie: The Cisco logo is tattooed on his arm and his dog's name is Cisco
20. View Brad Reese on Cisco Story Archives

• Careers
• Cisco
• Data Center
• LANs / WANs
• Boston technology attorney Lee Gesmer
• David Donatelli sued his former employer EMC in California state court
• Donatelli filed his California lawsuit
• Donatelli lost even though he hired famed Boston employment lawyer superstar Jay Shepherd
• Donatelli signed an EMC Key Employee Agreement which states
• EMC continued to remain very tight-lipped
• EMC countersued in Massachusetts state court seeking to have Donatelli's non-compete agreement enforced
• EMC is aware of the court's decision
• Famed Boston employment lawyer superstar Jay Shepherd
• Gesmer also noted in his blog
• Is Donatelli AWOL from EMC or just a simple no show at HP
• Judge Stephen Neel of the Massachusetts Suffolk County Superior Court in Boston
• Lee Gesmer blogged in his Mass Law Blog
• Lengths to which EMC has gone to impede Mr. Donatelli’s efforts to seek other employment
• Massachusetts court saw fit to delay Mr. Donatelli’s employment with HP
• Mr. Donatelli will be permitted to join HP in a leadership role
• View the entire 15 page EMC vs. Donatelli Decision below