10 Gigabit getting ready to go copper

While the fiber-based 10G Ethernet standard is less than a year old, the IEEE already is moving to create a copper-based version of the 802.3ae standard.

Two study groups formed in November are working on copper versions of 10G Ethernet with different approaches. One camp is backing a proposal for 10GBase-T, or 10G Ethernet over twisted-pair wiring, such as Category 5e or Cat 6 cabling. Another group is exploring 10G Ethernet over four pairs of twin-axial cabling - used previously in older IBM midrange server connectivity. Both versions are expected to reduce the cost of 10 Gigabit technology, which ranges from $17,000 to $80,000 per port.

While twisted-pair is the convention for wiring corporations with copper cabling, electrical limitations on the cabling could complicate the 10GBase-T.

To continue reading, register here and become an Insider. You'll get free access to premium content from CIO, Computerworld, CSO, InfoWorld, and Network World. See more Insider content or sign in.

While the fiber-based 10G Ethernet standard is less than a year old, the IEEE already is moving to create a copper-based version of the 802.3ae standard.

Two study groups formed in November are working on copper versions of 10G Ethernet with different approaches. One camp is backing a proposal for 10GBase-T, or 10G Ethernet over twisted-pair wiring, such as Category 5e or Cat 6 cabling. Another group is exploring 10G Ethernet over four pairs of twin-axial cabling - used previously in older IBM midrange server connectivity. Both versions are expected to reduce the cost of 10 Gigabit technology, which ranges from $17,000 to $80,000 per port.

While twisted-pair is the convention for wiring corporations with copper cabling, electrical limitations on the cabling could complicate the 10GBase-T.

"We were really pushing the limit of [twisted- pair wiring] technology when we hit 1000Base-T," says Brad Booth, chair of the IEEE 10GBase-T study group, and a chief architect with Intel. Booth says he does not expect to see 10GBase-T gear available until 2004 or 2005.

A twin-axial cable, with its thicker-gauge wiring, has been deemed less tricky. A draft is expected by March, and a standard could be set by year-end.

The two variations also would have different roles, Booth says. With twin-axial, connection ranges would be short - between 50 and 100 feet - with the target application being short switch-to-switch or server interconnects in a data center. Cat 5 or 6 would be able to reach about 300 feet, which could let users to run 10G Ethernet across installed horizontal structured cabling plants.

Whichever standard wins, a copper version of 10G Ethernet is seen as a way to keep down the price of the technology.

"Historically, copper has been the lowest price and highest volume" media for Ethernet, Booth says. Experts estimate that a copper version of 10 Gigabit could be 50% less expensive to produce than fiber-based switch ports and network interface cards.

Vendors also say they are readying products. Chip makers such as Solarflare and Broadcom have said they are developing copper-based 10 Gigabit silicon, and switch maker Force10 Networks hints that it could have a copper-based 10-Gigabit blade by year-end.

Read more about lans & wans in Network World's LANs & WANs section.