IETF, ITU form first-of-kind group to resolve MPLS spat - Network World

Skip Links

DNSstuff.com
Get information about your IP
IP Information
50+ On-demand DNS and network tools

LANs & WANs

Videos

rssRss Feed
Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, executive guides are added to our library.  Stay informed and up-to-date with the latest on IT Technologies with Network World's Resource Alerts.
Audio

Router/server consolidation: Dave Roberts. Listen now!

LinuxCast

Cisco's "Big Bang"; Sprint blamed for poor RadioShack sales. Listen now!

Network World 360

Additional Resources

RSS

FEATURED WHITEPAPERS

Edison Group TCO White Paper HP

Edison analysts put the management software of an HP EVA system through a series of typical day-to-day storage management tasks. The same tasks were also evaluated on similar systems from NetApp and EMC. This study demonstrates how the superior user interface and virtualization offered by the HP EVA storage system can provide organizations with the benefits of higher administrative efficiency combined with the potential ability to utilize less expensive human resources.

RSS

FEATURED REPORTS

Executive Guide: Storage Heats Up HP

Get the latest on storage technologies that allow IT professionals to better cope with new IT demands. Learn how storage technologies can help you successfully tackle e-Discover, regulatory compliance, green data center initiatives and the data explosion. Get all the details now.

RSS

FEATURED WEBCASTS

Reduce the Complexity and Cost of Windows Server Consolidation in Six Modules Novell

Watch this webcast to learn in six modules how to more cost effectively consolidate your Windows servers with virtualization. This unique program allows you to pick and choose which of the six modules you would like to view or watch the entire webcast at once. Topics covered: Performance, Use Cases, Enterprise-level Support, Managing Windows Workloads, Setup and Configuration and The Future. Find out how you can simplify server consolidation within your organization today. Register below to learn more and be entered to win an Archos 605 Portable Media Player.

IT Buyer's Guides

View All Buyer's Guides

Free Newsletters

Sign up and receive the latest news, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics

Save The Date!
What They Are Saying

If Microsoft does nothing to fix the problem in a timely manner, that is wrong and makes for poor business...- Anonymous

Join the Discussion

Partner Content

Cure Poor Application Performance

Nets often take the blame for slow performance when the culprit is poor running apps. Learn how to find the source of the problem.

Download whitepaper now

Improve your Network View

Better manage IT projects, solve network problems and support IT initiatives with integrated network analysis solutions.

Read Whitepaper Now

Rogue Wireless Access Points

Understand the methods of how to keep your wireless network secure.

Learn More Now

IETF, ITU form first-of-kind group to resolve MPLS spat

Cisco, others address proposed spec for MPLS over Ethernet
By Carolyn Duffy Marsan , Network World , 02/28/2008
  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Feedback 
  • Close

The Internet's leading standards bodies have joined forces to clarify a set of next-generation network transport specifications that critics warned could cause massive interoperability problems for service providers.

The Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) formed a joint working group in February to reconsider a special transport network architecture the ITU is developing for MPLS traffic.

Dubbed T-MPLS, the ITU specification would allow MPLS to run over an Ethernet backbone. It would work as an interim layer between Ethernet and MPLS, and carry only MPLS traffic.

The joint working group — the first ever formed by the IETF and ITU — hopes to settle a rare, public spat that developed between the two standards bodies last summer after the IETF charged that T-MPLS was incompatible with the existing MPLS standards.

IETF experts warned the ITU last summer that its T-MPLS specification would not work with the billions of dollars in routers and switches that carriers have installed in recent years based on the IETF's MPLS standards (See Standards vs. Proprietary: One of Networking's 50 Greatest Arguments.)

If left unchanged, T-MPLS would cause "a major train wreck" with MPLS, said Stewart Bryant, IETF liaison to the ITU-T on MPLS issues and a technical leader at Cisco. At an IETF meeting last July, Bryant called the T-MPLS situation "catastrophic."

Now the IETF and ITU are formally teaming up to try to avert this.

"The T-MPLS train is still rolling, and it's yet to be determined whether or not the train wreck is averted. But to keep the analogy going, we've found the train's controls: the gas pedal and the brake pedal. Before, we didn't know where the brakes were," says David Ward, one of the directors of the IETF's routing area who will serve as co-chair of the Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS. Ward is a Fellow with Cisco.

The ITU's Telecommunication Standardization Sector, known as ITU-T, established the Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS on Feb. 11 at the plenary meeting of its Study Group 15. The joint working group is the formalization of a plan that the IETF and ITU-T announced last September to try to work together on T-MPLS.

The Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS consists of around 70 network engineers from leading network equipment vendors including Cisco, Nortel, Alcatel-Lucent, Fujitsu, Huawei, Zte and Ericsson.

"The goal of the group is to clarify the differences and similarities between MPLS and T-MPLS and to make a recommendation to the ITU-T management about whether to go with Option 1, which is to make the two technologies completely consistent and compatible, or to go with Option 2, which is to declare them different and therefore change the name of T-MPLS and have different codepoints," explains Malcolm Betts, chairman of the ITU working group developing T-MPLS and the other co-chair of the Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS. Betts is a network engineer with Nortel Networks.

Betts says the Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS will make a recommendation to the ITU-T to go with Option 1 or Option 2 by the end of April.

Both Betts and Ward say members of the Ad Hoc Group are optimistic that they can make T-MPLS and MPLS interoperable.

"The group is leaning toward Option 1," Betts says. "It would be a technical roadblock that forced us into Option 2, and so far we haven't found one."

"As of this week, everybody is working to Option 1, and we haven't found any showstoppers," Ward says.

Whether it goes with Option 1 or Option 2, the Ad Hoc Group on T-MPLS is expected to complete its work by September 2009.

"The IETF and the ITU have worked quite extensively in the past, but this is the first time things got so publicly heated that we needed to have a special group to focus on it," Betts admits.

The ITU-T has been developing T-MPLS for two years, and it was almost done with the specification last summer when the IETF sent a strongly worded letter to the director of the ITU outlining its concerns about T-MPLS.

The IETF says the problem is that T-MPLS uses the same EtherType as MPLS, which will lead to confusion in operational networks. An EtherType is a field in the Ethernet networking standard that indicates which protocol is being transported.

1 | 2 |  Next >
Comments (1)
Login
Forgot your account info?

RE: IETF, ITU form first-of-kind group to resolve MPLS spatBy Rob Gasparik on February 28, 2008, 3:55 pmThe MPLS community is arguing while PBT is gaining momentum.

Reply | Read entire comment

View all comments

Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to moderator approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.
First Name
Last Name
E-mail
Zip Code