In the way that really only an online discussion can, the debate over which place is better, Seattle or Silicon Valley, has spun into a gloves-are-off, let's-take-this-outside kind of brawl.

It got kicked off with a brief New York Times article about Seattle becoming the next Silicon Valley. Shortly after, Seattle-based Redfin's CEO Glenn Kelman wrote a blog post about his experiences with startups in both locations. It was met with a harsh response from Michael Arrington, who has worked at a number of startups, on TechCrunch. And from there, the slugfest was on.

Silicon Valley folk bristled at the suggestion that the valley might not be "the" place to find the brightest minds and the deepest pockets, and they jeered at Seattlites for being more interested in snowboarding and kayaking than work. Seattlites rebutted that they have it all: exciting careers in hot startups and evenings skiing in the nearby mountains.

The reality, venture capitalists and startups say, is that Silicon Valley undoubtedly has far more money to be had, as well as more entrepreneurial computer scientists. But Seattle has a growing amount of cash and a fair amount of talent.

"Seattle has arrived in the big leagues," said Scott Darling, a general partner at Frazier Technology Ventures in Seattle. "We're not Silicon Valley, nobody is, but we're playing for real." Darling lived in Silicon Valley from the mid-1970s to 1990, when Andy Grove, one of Intel's founders, asked him to move to the Northwest to continue working for Intel. Darling said Washington state is now tied with Texas for third place in terms of VC money, behind Silicon Valley and Boston.

The recent boom in Seattle could be partly due to Microsoft's decreasing stature as a cutting-edge technology leader, at least according to one theory from an investor. Silicon Valley and Boston both boomed after a great company began to slow down -- in the valley, it was Fairchild, and in Boston, Digital Equipment -- leading bright minds to leave and start their own businesses, said Jeff Schrock, a partner at Monster Venture Partners in Seattle, who used to work for Yahoo in California.

"I think we're at an interesting stage in Seattle with Microsoft becoming more of a slow and steady growth company," he said. "For the first time, there are lots of people coming out of Microsoft looking for entrepreneurial opportunities."

The IDG News Service is a Network World affiliate.