Skip Links

Network World

  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Close

(Comma separation for multiple addresses)
Your Message:

Enterasys users should welcome Siemens deal -- for now, analysts say

Longer-term issues on market penetration, Cisco alternative will come
By Jim Duffy , Network World , 07/31/2008
  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print

Enterasys Networks customers should be encouraged that the joint venture between Enterasys owner Gores Group and Siemens strengthens the vendor's product portfolio and financial wherewithal.

Gores and Siemens this week entered into a joint venture in which Gores acquired a controlling stake in Enterprise Communications group, the No. 4 vendor in VoIP equipment worldwide, according to Dell'Oro Group. Gores plans to combine Enterasys and its SER Systems call-center company with Siemens Enterprise Communications to form a $5 billion provider of VoIP systems and Ethernet switches for enterprises.


View our slide show of 2008's hottest tech M&A deals.


The joint venture should present a more formidable challenge to Cisco's enterprise dominance and satisfy Enterasys' stated goal of more than doubling in size to become  a more credible alternative to the networking giant.

Existing Enterasys users should be heartened by the plan, says Rob Whiteley of Forrester Research.

"I think Enterasys customers should be thrilled," Whiteley says. "Enterasys was taken private [in 2006] and has pretty much remained silent for quite a long time. Given some of the financial viability concerns, I think a lot of current customers wanted any sign that there was light at the end of the Gores Group tunnel. Siemens provides the brand, some cash and a promise for a more stable revenue stream," he says.

"I don't really see any problem for customers," says Steve Schuchart of Current Analysis. "If anything, it means that Gores is more committed to Enterasys than ever. They kind of need [Enterasys] to make the whole thing work," he says.

Zeus Kerravala of The Yankee Group also believes Enterasys customers should be encouraged by the deal. There is always the potential for downside, however, he notes. Siemens has a professional services group that does a significant amount of business with Cisco and Cisco customers, he says. Also, Siemens' HiPath and OpenScape IP telephony systems most likely ride on Cisco networks.

"Siemens has got to be careful how much they position Enterasys as part of the [VoIP] solution," Kerravala says. "That could be a deterrent" for enterprises heavily entrenched in Cisco infrastructure, he says.

Forrester's Whiteley says the joint venture's challenge will come in convincing new customers to adopt its vision and products.

"It's the prospective customers that worry me," Whiteley says. "How does this marriage make any sense for them? There's no product-portfolio advantage; and Cisco, Alcatel-Lucent, 3Com, Nortel[with Microsoft] and even HP ProCurve [with partners] offer good switch plus [unified communications] solutions. I'm not even sure there's a financial angle as many of the other vendors can simply respond with deeper discounts if they feel the competitive pressure."

The true test for the joint venture will be long-term, when new products are spun from the union, Current Analysis' Schuchart says. That's when the biggest questions concerning viability and credibility as a Cisco alternative emerge as well.

  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print

Comments (6)
Login
Forgot your account info?

Completely misreading the marketBy bithead on August 1, 2008, 1:51 pmI think the announcement is a positive one and folks should be more interested in the possibilities in the area of future acquisitions. You dont have to compete...

Reply | Read entire comment

Enterprise bewareBy Anonymous on August 1, 2008, 7:45 pmI can see why the Enterasys installed base might be happier, but otherwise there's lots of questions for anyone considering Gores SEN. http://blog.tmcnet.com/the-hyperconnected-enterprise/business-aspects/gores-siemens-acquisition-more-challenges-ahead-for-customers.asp

Reply | Read entire comment

Nortel FUDBy Anonymous on August 1, 2008, 11:51 pmI read the comment by Tony R of Nortel in response to the announcement of the Siemens/Gores partnership. I posted on TMCnet that I thought post was irresponsible...

Reply | Read entire comment

Full Ack. First of all, itBy SL on August 2, 2008, 3:11 pmFull Ack. First of all, it should be clear for everybody outside, that Tonys statement is marketing blabla. And the message of SEN was and will be OPEN. That means...

Reply | Read entire comment

EnterysysBy Anonymous on August 17, 2008, 9:50 pmYou have to be kidding me? If I was an IT Director/CTO, there is NO way I would consider TWO diseperate technologies let alone companies. They will never make this...

Reply | Read entire comment

Enterasys routinely beats cisco in the security space.By Michael Patterson on September 2, 2008, 9:02 pmI agree with bithead regarding Enterasys security position. I'm also impressed with Enterasys being the only vendor outside of Cisco to support NetFlow on a switch....

Reply | Read entire comment

View all comments

Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.

Videos

rssRss Feed