Skip Links

Network World

  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Close

(Comma separation for multiple addresses)
Your Message:

Oracle subpoenas firm that hired ex-TomorrowNow workers

By Chris Kanaracus , IDG News Service , 11/20/2008
  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print

Oracle has subpoenaed a Colorado IT services firm that hired former employees of TomorrowNow, the now-defunct SAP subsidiary that provided third-party support services for Oracle's Siebel, PeopleSoft and JD Edwards product lines.

Oracle sued SAP last year, claiming TomorrowNow workers illegally downloaded material from Oracle's support systems and used it to woo Oracle customers. SAP has said TomorrowNow workers made "inappropriate downloads" from Oracle's Web site but has denied Oracle's allegations of a wider pattern of wrongdoing. SAP subsequently shut down TomorrowNow after failing to find a buyer for the subsidiary.

Now Oracle wants Spinnaker Management Group of Denver to turn over "documents sufficient to show any past, current or planned support by you of any Oracle customer," according to the subpoena dated Oct. 17.

In addition, Oracle is demanding Spinnaker hand over "all documents related to your evaluation, consideration or assessment of TomorrowNow, including but not limited to your evaluation of TomorrowNow's method of providing third-party services, business model, or the legality of TomorrowNow's method of providing third-party services."

Spinnaker created a JD Edwards support practice in August, saying it had hired the JD Edwards global support team from TomorrowNow.

Spinnaker has filed a motion to quash Oracle's subpoena, arguing in part that it is overly broad, seeks confidential customer information and "imposes undue burden" on Spinnaker.

An attorney for Spinnaker said the company would not comment.

Meanwhile, Oracle has also served a subpoena to CedarCrestone, an Alpharetta, Georgia, integrator and managed services provider that specializes in PeopleSoft, according to a joint discovery document filed Nov. 18 in the California federal court that is hearing the SAP-Oracle lawsuit.

"Apparently, certain former TomorrowNow customers have elected to get support from CedarCrestone rather than return to Oracle," SAP said. "Oracle's subpoena includes, among other things, a request for production of documents reflecting CedarCrestone's business model." The company could not immediately be reached Thursday.

An Oracle spokeswoman declined to comment.

At the root of the Oracle-SAP dispute is the fact that software maintenance revenue, charged as a percentage of a customer’s license cost, is a high-margin business that is becoming increasingly strategic to vendors’ finances, and third-party support providers stand to cut into that pie.

Oracle generated US$1.2 billion in services revenue out of a total $5.3 billion during the first quarter of its fiscal 2009, a 9 percent jump.

  • Share/Email
  • Tweet This
  • Comment
  • Print

Partner Content

Gartner 2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling

Gartner has positioned BMC CONTROL-M in the Leaders Quadrant of their "2009 Magic Quadrant for Job Scheduling." The report assesses the ability to execute and completeness of vision of key vendors in the marketplace. Read a full copy today, courtesy of BMC Software.

Download whitepaper

Dell's SMART Approach to Workload Automation

Read a compelling case study by EMA, Inc. to learn how Dell uses BMC CONTROL-M to cut cost and increase productivity with workload automation.

Download whitepaper

Workload Automation Cost Savings 2 Minute Video

A major computer manufacturer uses BMC CONTROL-M and just four people to schedule and run over 85,000 jobs every month. By switching to BMC CONTROL-M, they more than quadrupled the workload without adding a single staff member.  See how in this 2-minute video overview.

Go to video

Comments (2)
Login
Forgot your account info?

Oracle...no new products, lots of new lawsuitsBy Anonymous on November 23, 2008, 8:01 pmI guess Oracle figures that in the absence of innovation or positive customer satisfaction to drive revenues, they'll just try to LITIGATE the competition to death!...

Reply | Read entire comment

something's fishy...By Anonymous on November 23, 2008, 8:05 pmIf Rimini Street has taken the greatest number of customer refugees from TomorrowNow, but Oracle has skipped over the next largest player in the industry to go to...

Reply | Read entire comment

View all comments

Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.

Videos

rssRss Feed