Skip Links

Managing Cloud Complexity

Mac OS X Snow Leopard vs. Mac OS X Lion

Concerns raised over iOSification of the Mac OS, but benefits seem to outweigh drawbacks with latest Apple software

By , Network World
November 02, 2011 06:09 AM ET

Network World - The Snow Leopard version of Mac OS X released in 2009 was widely hailed by Mac users. The version was leaner, much faster and more thoroughly integrated with applications than ever before. And then Apple unveiled its plans for the Lion version in late 2010.

There were concerns that the planned changes would slow down the Mac OS. But most of all there was skepticism about Apple's intent to make the Mac OS X look and behave more like iOS, the touch firmware for its iPhones and iPads.

THE LATEST: Apple roars about OS X Mountain Lion downloads topping 3 million

Lion, or formally Mac OS X 10.7, was finally released July 20, 2011, with over 250 new features. Those included multi-touch gestures, system-wide support for full screen apps, revamped Mail application, a new way to see easily all running applications and active windows (called Mission Control), the now-built-in Mac App Store (analogous to the iOS App Store for finding and downloading programs), and Launchpad, a full-screen, grid-like display of available applications, which can be re-arranged and grouped into folders.

NETWORK WORLD's HOTTEST TECH ARGUMENTS: Read them all here

SLIDESHOW: Mac OS X Lion's top 20 features

The next day, Apple announced a million downloads had already taken place, making Lion the fastest-selling Mac OS release in the company's history. Two months later, by the end of Apple's fourth quarter, another 5 million had downloaded it, perhaps in part enticed by a dramatic price cut, to $30 from $129. Apple also announced a new record for Mac sales: 4.89 million, or 760,000 more than in any previous quarters. For the fiscal year, Mac sales totaled 16.8 million, bringing the total number of Mac users worldwide to about 60 million.

A speed test comparison by CNET found almost no meaningful difference between Snow Leopard and Lion. "At least on our benchmark tests, it appears that Lion will provide the same speedy performance as its predecessor," wrote CNET's Rich Brown. 

Lifehacker concurred. "Overall, with the exception of the application launching test it seems like there are few differences in speed between the two operating systems," wrote Adam Dachis. Lion took a bit longer to launch applications, but loaded Websites faster, and was considerably faster in file compression.

But the "iOSification" of the Mac continues to divide users. Infoworld's Galen Gruman detailed six "Lion Letdowns," most of them related to this trend. 

And Erica Saudan, at TheUnofficialAppleWeblog, posted on "Lion: Ten things that bug me.

"Taking aspects of the iPad and iPhone into Mac OS X makes a lot of sense, just as iOS took so much from Mac OS X -- they both share the core code, after all," Gruman writes. A successful example: the new user interface for the Mac's Mail application, which is a "nice adaptation from the iPad's Mail app." And adding gestures for Macs, via touch-aware input devices such as the newer Mac's touchpad or Apple's Magic Mouse or Magic Trackpad is another plus.

But there are misses, he says, such as Mac OS X Launchpad, modeled after the grid-like home screen on the iPhone or iPad. "It may sound great to have all your apps in a grid on your screen, but it's not," Gruman says. "On a computer screen, the grid is overwhelmingly large, and the order in which apps appears is essentially random. Sure, you can create folders and rearrange them, but it's a lot of work to do something that the [previous version's] Dock and the Finder windows for your Applications folder and Utilities folder handle much better."

Our Commenting Policies
Latest News
rssRss Feed
View more Latest News