Skip Links

Tech Arguments 2012

IETF vs. ITU: Internet standards face-off

All eyes on World Conference on International Telecommunications in Dubai

By , Network World
December 03, 2012 07:09 AM ET

Network World - A battle is brewing between two standards bodies - the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) - over which group will be the primary source of the underlying communications protocols that allow the Internet to operate in the future.

Read Network World's other tech arguments.

RELATED: The non-Internet that never was but might be 

Since 1986, the IETF has been the Internet's primary standards body. The all-volunteer group of network engineers has developed many of the most popular Internet standards including the Internet Protocol and the next-generation IPv6 through a process committed to "rough consensus and running code." Among the IETF's hundreds of innovations are standards for e-mail, domain names, network management and VoIP.

Bullet Apple iOS vs. Google Android: It comes down to security
Bullet Tablet smackdown: iPad vs Surface RT in the enterprise
Bullet Cisco, VMware and OpenFlow fragment SDNs
Bullet Cloud computing showdown: Amazon vs. Rackspace (OpenStack) vs. Microsoft vs. Google
Bullet Cisco Catalyst 6500 vs. Cisco Nexus 700

The ITU, on the other hand, was established in 1865 to ease connectivity of the first telegraph and then telephone networks. Today it oversees global radio spectrum, satellite orbits and other carrier-centric technologies through formal development and review processes. The ITU's members include countries and private companies, rather than individuals. It has created popular standards for video compression, broadband and wave division multiplexing.

Until now, the ITU has mostly taken a hands-off approach to the Internet. But that could change in December, when the World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT) is held in Dubai. This two-week conference will be the first major revision of the international treaties that define the ITU's role since 1988.

The WCIT will make changes to the International Telecommunication Regulations - or ITR - which facilitate global interconnection and interoperability of telecommunications traffic. The ITR sets rules for traffic flows, quality of service as well as routing and billing between network operators.

The Internet Society, which is the umbrella organization for the IETF as well as a member of the ITU, is concerned about the ITU taking a harder line on Internet governance. ISOC argues that it is critical that the Internet retain key principles in the future, specifically that it allow for open access, permission-less innovation and collaboration in order for it to continue to be an engine of economic growth.

ISOC is concerned about proposals from ITU member states that deal with such issues as peering arrangements because this could impact the cost of international Internet traffic and how users pay for Internet services. Other proposals could give governments more leeway with regard to censorship and content control or could limit data privacy. Governments could get involved in Internet address allocation, which is currently handled by the regional Internet registries. Another worry is that more regulation by the ITU will result in a slowing of innovation on the Internet.

Our Commenting Policies
Latest News
rssRss Feed
View more Latest News