Skip Links

EFF: Trust Twitter -- but not Apple or Verizon -- to protect your privacy

Report reveals tech companies that actively protect user information from government scrutiny

By , Network World
April 30, 2013 05:11 PM ET

Network World - Verizon and MySpace scored a zero out of a possible six stars in a test of how far 18 technology service providers will go to protect user data from government data demands.

Twitter and Internet service provider scored a perfect six in the third annual Electronic Frontier Foundation "Who Has Your Back?" report.

[ RELATED: EFF urges court to protect privacy of text messages

ONGOING: Facebook weighs in on privacy of its Home Android app ]

The purpose of the report is to inform the public about how well privacy is protected but also to encourage lagging companies to do better and to be more transparent about the requests for data they receive from government agencies, says EFF Senior Staff Attorney Marcia Hofmann.

Apple, AT&T and Yahoo each scored just one star, ranking at the bottom with Verizon and MySpace.

Verizon and MySpace are chronically at the bottom of the heap, the report says. "We remain disappointed by the overall poor showing of ISPs like AT&T and Verizon in our best practice categories," it says.

Dropbox, Google, LinkedIn and SpiderOak all scored five out of six to tie for second place behind Twitter and

The remaining seven companies that fell somewhere in between are: Amazon (2); Comcast (2); Facebook (3); Foursquare (4); Microsoft (4); Tumblr (3); and WordPress (4).

The companies are measured in six categories and given a star or not. The categories: Requiring warrants before delivering content; telling users about government requests for their data; publishing reports that list agencies that made requests; publishing guidelines they have for responding to government requests; going to court to fight for users privacy; lobbying Congress to establish privacy rights by joining the Digital Due Process coalition .

The report comes down pretty hard on Amazon, Facebook, Yahoo, Apple and AT&T. "Amazon holds huge quantities of information as part of its cloud computing services and retail operations, yet does not promise to inform users when their data is sought by the government, produce annual transparency reports, or publish a law enforcement guide," the report says.

"Facebook has yet to publish a transparency report. Yahoo! has a public record of standing up for user privacy in courts, but it hasn't earned recognition in any of our other categories. Apple and AT&T are members of the Digital Due Process coalition, but don't observe any of the other best practices we're measuring."

In the report Google is singled out as backsliding on whether it notifies users when the government asks to see their data. The company introduced ambiguity into its stance and so lost credit it had been awarded in previous years, the report says.

Google also earned special recognition for challenging a National Security Letter demanding access to user data. A star is awarded "when a company goes above and beyond for its users, as Google did this year," the EFF report says. Microsoft earned similar praise.

Microsoft and Twitter both started publishing transparency reports this year, joining five others, the report notes.

Our Commenting Policies
Latest News
rssRss Feed
View more Latest News