News grab bag: FMC, free Wi-Fi, Google Phone and our perspectives
Global phone services; metro Wi-Fi moves slowly; Google’s Google Phone
Convergence & VoIP Alert
By
Steve Taylor
and
Larry Hettick
,
Network World
, 09/12/2007
Sign up for this newsletter now!
Steve Taylor and Larry Hettick offer news and analysis on the latest in IP convergence from fixed-mobile convergence, presence management, IP video and unified communications.
- Share/Email
- Tweet This
- Print
Today, we’d like to highlight a few announcements and developments in the news that affect convergence. The first report comes
from the United Nations International Telecommunications Union (ITU) which estimates that global phone service has quadrupled
over the past decade to four billion lines, which includes 1.27 billion fixed lines and 2.68 billion mobile subscribers; some
61% of mobile customers live in “developing countries.” Our analysis: While fixed mobile convergence move along at a snail’s
pace, perhaps the popularity of mobile access will help carriers pick up the pace of deployments. And for those who thought
that telecom was a dying industry, to paraphrase the saying, the reports of telecom’s demise “may have been greatly exaggerated.”
Second, on metro Wi-Fi and WiMAX deployments moving slowly. Some cities like Chicago have delayed or abandoned their plans
to partner with companies like EarthLink to offer free wireless broadband access across the metro-area for all local citizens
because the expense is much greater than expected, subscriber counts are lower than projected, and the model of using ad revenues
and a few paid subscribers to subsidize the difference doesn’t seem to be working well. Our analysis harkens back to the demise
of “free” (dial-up) Internet access models from about 10 years ago and can be summarized by the song lyrics “When will they
ever learn?”
Third, on reports that Google might be working on a “Google Phone” and that it is in the running for the upcoming FCC auction of wireless spectrum. Our analysis: While Google has been the
world’s best at generating revenues to compensate, the idea of a Google (maybe free) mobile phone seems to fly in the face
of the popular $600 iPhone, and we remain unconvinced about the prospects of a successful business model based on this approach.
Second, we’ve suggested that especially in the face of regulation or legislation against Google on ‘Net neutrality, Google
is smart to keep its access options open; just the threat of using wireless access to bypass companies like AT&T or Verizon’s
wireline broadband Internet access may contribute to a competitive environment. But (see second note above): we’re not sure
there’s any such thing as a free lunch.
Next time: an interview with Sir Terry Mathews.
Steve Taylor is president of Distributed Networking Associates and publisher/editor-in-chief of Webtorials. Larry Hettick is a principal analyst at Current Analysis.
Comment