- Insider threat looms large in San Francisco
- Woman fired over death threat
- IT admin pleads not guilty
- Tape storage gets more dense
- Top 10 worst uses for Windows
News | Newsletters | Podcasts | Chats | Opinions | RSS Feeds | This Week In Print | IT Careers | Community | Reports | Downloads | Slideshows | New Data Center
Partner Sites:App Performance | On Demand Security | Networking Solution | SOA | Value of WDS
The REAL ID Act: is currently the subject of hot debate in the Judiciary Committee of the U.S. Senate.
One proponent of the act says its purpose is “to make sure our driver’s licenses and government issued IDs can’t be faked. We need to hold employers accountable for hiring illegal workers, and real IDs will make this enforcement possible.” Even if one disapproves of the very idea of a national identity card, with all the privacy concerns that such a system raises, it’s hard to disagree that the burden of extra paperwork would inconvenience some illegal immigrants to the U.S. as well as imposing additional nuisances on citizens and legal residents requesting drivers’ licenses.
However, the Department of Homeland Security has a startling assertion on its Web site: “REAL ID is a nationwide effort intended to prevent terrorism.”
One category of objections is exactly analogous to opposition to gun-control laws: the laws won’t work because criminals will ignore them. For example, Rep. Ron Paul (R-Texas) wrote in 2005:
“One overriding point has been forgotten: Criminals don’t obey laws! As with gun control, national ID cards will only affect law-abiding citizens. Do we really believe a terrorist bent on murder is going to dutifully obtain a federal ID card? Do we believe that people who openly flout our immigration laws will nonetheless respect our ID requirements? Any ID card can be forged; any federal agency or state DMV is susceptible to corruption. Criminals can and will obtain national ID cards, or operate without them. National ID cards will be used to track the law-abiding masses, not criminals.”
By this reasoning, we would have no laws at all.
More on this topic in the next column.
Rss FeedRss Feed
All you guys are fighting about is the fact you can reset the routers. This was childs point. He created...- Daniel
| NetworkWorld, Inc. | About Network World, Inc. | Advertise | Careers | Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy | Reprints and links | Partnerships | Press room | Subscribe to NW |
| IDG, Inc. | CIO | Computerworld | CSO | Demo | GamePro | Games.net | IDGconnect.com | IDG World Expo | Infoworld | JavaWorld.com | LinuxWorld.com | MacUser | Macworld | PC World | Playlistmag.com | The Industry Standard | IDG List Services | IDG TechNetwork |
 |
Copyright © 1994-2008 Network World, Inc. All rights reserved. |
Partner Content
Brilliantly simple security and control solutions for email, web and endpoint
www.sophos.com
Stopping data leakage
Learn how to exploit your current security investment to control the information that flows into, through and out of your network.
Download the white paper.
Why detection rates aren't enough
Evaluating endpoint security products is a time-consuming and daunting task. Learn the six critical questions you need to ask to prospective vendors to get the right endpoint solution.
Download the white paper.
Unauthorized applications: Taking back control
Employees installing and using unauthorized applications like IM, VoIP, games and peer-to-peer file-sharing applications cause many businesses serious concern. How do you control these applications?
Download the white paper.
Comments (16)
Reponse to 911truthdotorgBy Anonymous on May 22, 2007, 3:13 pmDennis Kucinich?! I can see why you believe in blurry videos that make Repulicans look bad. Stop hiding behind the notion that you are interested in freedom...
Reply | Read entire comment
The Real ID Act is an Orwellian nightmare!By 911truthdotorg on May 18, 2007, 4:50 pmIt has NOTHING to do with our "safety". It is ALL about our control. If, God forbid, this ever comes to be, you'll need "your papers" at all times just like...
Reply | Read entire comment
Enforcement and Punishment vs. Another lawBy Anonymous on May 17, 2007, 3:52 pmThe one aspect of laws most pro-law people ignore is that of enforcement. We have over 20,000 laws limiting gun usage. Does that make us safe from crimials intent...
Reply | Read entire comment
debate over national ID cards - number 1By Anonymous on May 17, 2007, 12:58 pmAny law is a blance between pain for the individual who is law abiding and consequences for those who do not abide with the law. Those who are not in favor of the...
Reply | Read entire comment
National ID or NotBy jake4pizza on May 16, 2007, 7:17 pmI think it's a given "YES" we need a system to give the people graduating college - jobs. It's a thing about make work off the backs of the society you live in....
Reply | Read entire comment
View all comments