Password management: Facing the problem
Passfaces has a novel alternative to passwords
Security Strategies Alert
By
M. E. Kabay
,
Network World
, 10/11/2007
Sign up for this newsletter now!
Mich Kabay takes a high-level view of security issues and provides resources to help safeguard your corporate and personal security.
- Share/Email
- Tweet This
- Print
In my last two columns, I’ve been looking at the pervasive problems we have in the security field in overcoming natural human tendencies to misjudge
risk. In particular, I’ve pointed out that the well-known and documented tendency of normal people to write down passwords
is a consequence of deep-seated difficulties we face in our in-built abilities to interpret and manage risk.
When I was reconnecting recently with an old friend from my NCSA (National Computer Security Association) days in the 1990s,
I visited her employer’s Web site and found an interesting method for helping users avoid writing down their passwords (or
choosing bad ones or even sharing them casually): Passfaces.
This software allows users to pick out recognizable faces that will authenticate them to their systems. Perhaps the best introduction
is to look at the “Online User Manual” posted about the free “Passfaces Personal” product that anyone can download and try.
The basic idea is that a user sets up an array of photographs and puts some familiar ones into the pool to use as keys - the
faces of people the user recognizes - then the software can produce a 3-by-3 grid of random selections, including one of the
key pictures. The user picks out the familiar picture and then repeats the exercise twice more with new sets of eight strangers
and one friend to authenticate the user.
Versions are available for Windows, for Web-site access control and for financial applications.
Passfaces offers a number of useful case studies and good PDF brochures about its products. I especially liked their white paper on “The Science Behind Passfaces,” which explains how human beings are particularly good at recognizing faces; indeed, it seems that we have special circuits
that have evolved for rapid and accurate perception of faces.
The paper cites the following as advantages of “using Passfaces over passwords” (quoting the list exactly):
* Can’t be written down or copied
* Can’t be given to another person
* Can’t be guessed
* Involve cognitive not memory skills
* Can be used as a single or part of a dual form of authentication
The power of the system is enhanced by setting parameters to interfere with misuse of the faces. For example:
“In some high-security applications the grids of faces may be displayed only for a very short time. A half second is long
enough for practiced users to recognize their Passfaces. Combined with masking (faces in a grid are overwritten with a common
mask face) it is extremely difficult for “shoulder surfers” to learn the Passfaces as the user clicks on them. Users can also
be given the option to enter the grid position of each Passfaces on a keypad, rather than picking them out on the screen.”
M. E. Kabay, PhD, CISSP-ISSMP, specializes in security and operations management consulting services. CV online.
Comments (5)
RE: Password management: Facing the problemBy Anonymous on October 11, 2007, 9:19 amThis method does not seem to cover the issue of shoulder surfing. Re: Password management: Facing the problem.
Reply | Read entire comment
Good idea but a nightmare to implementBy Shasikanth on October 11, 2007, 10:21 amWe had once tried get our users to register 3 secret questions that we could to authenticate when requesting password changes and I remember what a nightmare it...
Reply | Read entire comment
Wow! This is really great. IBy Eliza on October 15, 2007, 11:56 amWow! This is really great. I haven't heard until now about this method of authentication. I think it's really great and also it is more secure that other methods...
Reply | Read entire comment
Passfaces and Shoulder SurfingBy Steve Morck on January 16, 2008, 11:13 amPassfaces Personal users can utilize the numeric keyboard to select their faces rather than the mouse. If you’ll notice, the 3x3 grid maps nicely to a numeric keypad...
Reply | Read entire comment
Re: Nightmare to implementBy Steve Morck on January 17, 2008, 11:23 amI wanted to comment on the issue of implementation and user acceptance. First, I would agree that forcing users to choose 3 challenge questions was probably a difficult...
Reply | Read entire comment
View all comments