But the pain from a bad contract can last years and cost thousands,
even millions of dollars. In a worst-case scenario, you could wind up
buying gear or services your network doesnt really need, or enter
a relationship with an unresponsive or just plain bad vendor.
Frankly, too many IT buyers fail to employ good negotiating practices.
"Weve gotten called in to undo a lot of [badly done] deals,"
says Marlene Bauer, director of consulting services for International
Computer Negotiators (ICN), a Winter Park, Fla., firm that advises companies
negotiating major goods and services contracts.
How do bad deals happen? Usually because the IT manager lets the vendor
salespeople control negotiations or agrees to sign a standard contract.
Standard forms are littered with disclaimers of liability, granting
maximum protection to the vendor and minimum protection to you. A vendor
contract will not include service-level agreements, solid maintenance
policies and remedies if the vendor fails to perform unless you demand
them.
Youll be amazed at just how rock-solid IT contracts can be if
you take control of contract negotiations. It will also save you lots
of headaches - and money. According to Bauer, a formal procurement process
that includes the following power negotiating tactics can reduce costs
by 25% over the long run.
Prepare, prepare, prepare
Do your homework before you begin discussions with a vendor, says Ralph
Capio, an attorney with Armstrong Teasdale LLP in St. Louis and an instructor
with ESI International, a Washington, D.C., consultancy specializing
in contract management. "The better you prepare, the more likely
it is you will succeed in the negotiation," he says.
Preparation includes determining what you need and what you can live
without. Do you really require a 5-year maintenance contract for a server
you view as a temporary fix in an ongoing expansion? Or what about that
groupware application a vendor is offering free for 180 days? Is that
something you really want to bother with?
You also want to get an idea of what the vendor wants to accomplish
through your contract. Is a hardware manufacturer looking to place switches
its planning on phasing out soon? Or is a new e-commerce applications
vendor trying to establish a foothold in the market? In either case,
the vendor would probably be more willing than usual to discount prices.
Its up to you to know that and adjust your negotiating strategy
accordingly.
"If you know your interests and their interests, you can look
for that common ground that makes a win-win situation a possibility,"
Capio says. He adds that determining your vendors "walk-away
position" will help you bargain. Of course, skilled vendors will
also be evaluating you and using this information to improve their negotiating
leverage.
Establish a team
Creating a negotiating team with people outside of IT is a strategy
many network managers find hard to swallow. After all, who knows the
needs of IT better than you?
But flying solo into negotiations is a big mistake.
"A lot of times, the IT guys or women are out doing the deals
on their own, and they are really outclassed when it comes to the negotiations,"
says ICNs Bauer. "They are great technically, but they just
become pawns in the deal because they tend to be manipulated."
Bulk
up your side of the table with an experienced negotiator - such as a
procurement officer - and a team leader who can prioritize project needs
and translate them to a list of contract terms, she says. If you are
not the team leader, you should definitely be in a strong advisory position.
The team should also have someone from the legal department, a user
representative and even a human resources professional if the product
being negotiated will require the transfer of people.
Stay one step ahead of the vendor
Demand to see a vendors standard contract upfront. A good practice
is requiring vendors to submit contracts with their initial proposals.
Be prepared to meet some resistance. Salespeople often dont let
you see the contract until late in the game; they either dismiss it
as a mere formality or wait until you are so excited to get the goods
that you will turn against any colleague - including the company attorney
- who dares to question the deal.
When you get the contract, make sure it includes everything youve
asked to be included. Dont be surprised if your trusted salesman
neglects to attach equipment schedules, software and maintenance agreements
or other crucial supplements.
Make sure everyone on your team understands what is in the proposed
contract before sitting down at the negotiating table. This is also
a good time to have your companys legal department prepare the
changes you want to see in the contract. Dont be afraid to bring
up these changes during negotiations. "Its amazing how many
customers dont even realize how much leverage they really do have
and the kind of things they really can ask for," Bauer says.
Last, if you hear a discrepancy during the presentation, dont
hesitate to say "we want that written into the contract."
Dont fight your vendor
Some customers mistakenly treat negotiations as they would a war and
the vendor the enemy that must be crushed.
"Sometimes we define a win only in terms of somebody elses
loss," ESIs Capio says. "Now your interests dont
entirely coincide, but if you approach it as an adversarial event, then
you are more likely to strike a win-lose posture, as opposed to a win-win."
Power at the negotiating table doesnt mean beating a vendor over
the head, agrees Rich Glasberg, director of data communications for
the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and a veteran negotiator for network
goods and services. "The worst thing you can do is start negotiations
on a bad note, treating the vendor as if it owes you something. There
is no benefit to going in and closing the doors and butting heads."
While you dont want to go to war, you dont want to be a
pushover, either. Good salespeople are trained to find your soft spots
and exploit them.
Establishing a personal friendship is a common ploy for lowering defenses.
Once salespeople have gotten your trust, its easier for them to
get you to accept their word on technical and legal points.
Whatever you do, dont say youre in a hurry to get the gear.
If you do, you become a victim of a trap youve set. All it takes
is a few well-chosen words - "The factory tells me it has that
item with the specs you want, but they were going to ship it to a customer
in Pittsburgh next week" - to get you reaching for the pen. The
terms are never ideal, but who wants to wait another six months for
a piece of gear that should have been installed yesterday?
Furthermore, no matter how competent or up to the task the vendor seems,
dont tell the vendor its got your business until you put
pen to paper. "Once you award the deal [verbally], you lose leverage,"
Bauer says.
Whats the best way to slam on the brakes when youre feeling
rushed by the negotiations? Step back and remove the sense of urgency
created by yourself or the vendor.
Be flexible with deadlines, and ignore those brought up by the salesperson.
If you are unable to do this, or if the salesperson still tries to rush
you into closing the deal, its best to go to the vendors
top-level management. This tactic is also good when lower-level marketing
people are dragging their feet, playing games or are otherwise unresponsive
to your needs.
Remember, pushing for what you want might not be pleasant, but your
smile will be brighter after the contract is signed.
Top negotiating myths
By Ian Lamont"Were giving you our best price."
Dont think for a second that youre getting the best price
by virtue of your companys size, long-term relationship with the
vendor or anything else. A statement like this is meant to discourage
you from bargaining down the price, plain and simple.
"We dont need to write that down."
This chestnut often involves a "personal" relationship between
a well-trained marketing person and the customers key manager. After
trust has been established, the latter will be willing to accept anything
the salesperson says. But once the relationship ends (usually when one
of the two parties gets promoted or leaves the company) the customer is
stuck with the vendors one-sided contract.
"We can negotiate later."
Give your assent, and you can kiss any future negotiating leverage goodbye.
"Well do anything for our valued
customers."
Not if it isnt in writing. If the vendor insists its sincere,
then it should have no problem changing the contract to reflect this wonderful
attitude.
"The price is going up next month."
Hinting about an imminent price rise is a scare tactic designed to insert
a sense of urgency into the proceedings and encourage you to sign the
contract without proper evaluation or negotiation.
"Try it for 90 days - no obligation to
buy."
Who wouldnt want to get something for nothing? But dont think
its free. At the end of the trial period, youll hopefully
be so dependent on the product that you will not only have to buy it,
but also not even consider what the competition has to offer.
|