Review: Test of session border controller includes products from Ditech, Ingate, Mera and NexTone. - Network World

Skip Links

DNSstuff.com
Get information about your IP
IP Information
50+ On-demand DNS and network tools

VoIP & Convergence

Videos

rssRss Feed
Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, executive guides are added to our library.  Stay informed and up-to-date with the latest on IT Technologies with Network World's Resource Alerts.

Additional Resources

RSS

FEATURED WHITEPAPERS

Core PCI Requirements for Windows and Active Directory NetPro

The Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) is a set of industry regulations imposed by the major credit card companies to ensure the safety, security, and integrity of cardholder data. Any business that processes, stores, and transmits cardholder account data must comply with this complex new standard, and must be able to demonstrate that compliance through automated and manual audits of their systems. This white paper looks at the key challenges and requirements of PCI DSS as it relates to Microsoft Windows and Active Directory, and shows you how a third-party software solution can help with PCI compliance.

RSS

FEATURED REPORTS

Executive Guide: Storage Heats Up HP

Get the latest on storage technologies that allow IT professionals to better cope with new IT demands. Learn how storage technologies can help you successfully tackle e-Discover, regulatory compliance, green data center initiatives and the data explosion. Get all the details now.

RSS

FEATURED WEBCASTS

Reduce Complexity and Cost - Windows Server Consolidation with Virtualization from Novell Novell

There are many compelling reasons for virtualizing Windows and Linux applications. Virtualization improves server utilization by allowing you to run multiple workloads on a single physical server. It reduces the number of physical servers you have to maintain, while allowing you to use less physical space and power while still improving scalability. All of these capabilities translate directly into lower costs, less complexity, and greater flexibility in your mixed IT environment. Register below to learn more and be entered to win an Archos 605 Portable Media Player.

SBC 'traffic cop' controls VoIP streams at the border

Session border controllers, complex and costly, offer widely varying capabilities.
By Edwin Mier, Anthony Mosco, Robert Tarpley and Robert Smithers , Network World , 04/17/2006
  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Feedback 
  • Close
Clear Choice Test

Is there a session border controller in your enterprise's VoIP future? If you're looking to expand your organization's VoIP reach - to VoIP-based service providers, to other enterprises or even to VoIP-interconnected distributed sites via the Internet - there very well may be.

Click to see:

Error 500--Internal Server Error

Error 500--Internal Server Error

From RFC 2068 Hypertext Transfer Protocol -- HTTP/1.1:

10.5.1 500 Internal Server Error

The server encountered an unexpected condition which prevented it from fulfilling the request.

A word about performance

In this inaugural test of session border controllers (SBC), it was not our intent to get into the minutiae of product performance, because SBCs have disparate feature sets and deployment options. That said, we can make some general assessments about SBCs based on the results of our sending modest levels of Session Initiation Protocol call traffic through them. SBCs' effects on call quality varied from essentially no degradation (mean opinion score [MOS] of 4.5, R-factor of 93) to measurable degradation (MOS of 3.9, R-factor of 85). SBCs also could add to call-setup time and latency; the extent appears to vary based on the power of the SBC hardware platform.

Functionally, an SBC is a traffic cop: It facilitates and mediates VoIP flows in real time, in both directions between private VoIP domains: an enterprise and a VoIP-based service provider - the environment we tested here - or two service providers. SBCs came of age by providing peering connectivity between different carriers' VoIP services and only recently have begun penetrating enterprises.


How we tested SBCs
Archive of Network World tests
Subscribe to the Network Product Test Results newsletter

There is no universal job description for an SBC. Certainly there has to be versatile handling of VoIP call-control protocols, such as Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) and H.323, especially amid different firewall and network address translation (NAT) configurations. And there needs to be some security safeguards - hiding the network topology of the private network, for example. But overall, SBCs are complex and costly components, coming from diverse backgrounds and offering widely varying capabilities.

We invited more than a dozen vendors who were touting new SBC wares earlier this year to submit their packages for testing in Miercom's New Jersey lab. Four accepted our challenge for this feature-based testing: Ditech Communications, Ingate Systems, Mera Systems and NexTone Communications.

Despite many differences in the feature sets of these products (see "What SBCs do" ), their general orientations lie in a few similar, basic areas, including VoIP call handling, QoS handling and security capabilities. Based on our assessment in these areas, our Clear Choice Test Award goes to NexTone's package, the Multiprotocol Session Controller (MSC) coupled with its iView Management System (iVMS). NexTone's dynamic VoIP session control, real-time monitoring with active error and threshold-limit notification, call-level reporting system, and integrated firewall features make it the best of the enterprise-focused SBCs we tested. We note, though, that the NexTone package costs considerably more than the competition (more than $100,000, compared with $25,000 to $38,000 for the others).

Click to see:

What session border controllers do: Comparative feature checklist
Note: A check mark (√) indicates the product fully addresses this feature.
VoIP signaling and call handling
Ditech PeerPoint C100
Ingate SIParator 60
Mera MVTS
NexTone MSC and iVMS
Call load, bandwidth optimization        
Full-featured firewall traversal  
Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) to H.323 conversion
H.323 gatekeeper services    
SIP proxy, redirect, other services
Real-time Transport Protocol/RTP Control Protocol termination and regeneration
 
Transcoding (G.711-G.729, etc.)    
 
IP address resolution/management
Security        
Native, integral firewall  
 
Topology hiding
Authenticate VoIP calls and callers
Open and close legacy firewall ports
   
VoIP network address translation
Prevention of denial-of-service attacks
 
QoS, quality monitoring, reporting        
Differentiated Services/types of services QoS handling
Monitors each VoIP call
Per-call quality rating (i.e., mean opinion score)    
Issue call detail records  
TCall-quality trend reports      

Next: NexTone Communications >

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |  Next >
Comment
Login
Forgot your account info?
Add comment
Anonymous comments subject to moderator approval. Register here for member benefits.
Have a NetworkWorld account? Log in here. Register now for a free account.
First Name
Last Name
E-mail
Zip Code
IT Buyer's Guides

View All Buyer's Guides