Skip Links

Network World

  • Social Web 
  • Email 
  • Close

Net results

By Ryan Francis , Network World , 07/28/2008
  • Share/Email
  • Comment
  • Print
FAS2050 (dual controllers) OVERALL RATING
4.2
Company:NetApp• www.netapp.com Cost: $69,960** Pros: Among highest performance in our tests; NAS and SAN features; heavy enterprise feature set; built-in high-availability capabilities; good snapshot agent support; expandable. Con: Very poor management interface needs revamp; two controllers separately managed.
StorageCenter OVERALL RATING
4.1
Company: Compellent Technologies • www.compellent.com Cost: $68,800 Pros: Very expandable; outstanding management interface; data migration feature reduces management costs; flexible snapshot features. Cons: Low space efficiency; high availability requires completely separate controller.
StorageWorks 2012i Modular Smart Array OVERALL RATING
4.1
Company: HP • www.hp.com Cost: $12,887 Pro: Mixes SAS and SATA drives in same chassis; easy expandability; above-average management toolset; built-in HA capabilities. Con: MPIO setup requires manual intervention; SATA performance poor.
PS5000XV OVERALL RATING
4.0
Company: Dell • www.dell.com/equallogic Cost: $55,000 Pro: Heavy set of enterprise features; among highest performance in our tests; built-in HA capabilities; easy expansion into cluster. Cons: Weak reporting features.
NSM 2120 Storage Node OVERALL RATING
3.9
Company: LeftHand Networks • www.lefthandnetworks.com Cost: $$96,000* Pro: Easy expansion and scalability; among highest performance in our tests; easy configuration for iSCSI initiators. Cons: Management model restrictive; high price for minimum high-availability configuration.
Storage Concentrator OVERALL RATING
3.9
Company: StoneFly • www.stonefly.com Cost: $$26,436**** Pro: Very good performance for SATA-based system; simple GUI; good performance for SATA-based system; expandable with additional disk shelves over Fibre Channel; simple GUI. Cons: Unmanaged external arrays.
NSS-S12 OVERALL RATING
3.7
Company: FalconStor Software • www.falconstor.com Cost: $43,000 Pro: Strong snapshot agent support; strong replication feature set. Cons: No expansion capabilities; poor integration between RAID controller and rest of system.
9240 Unified Storage Gateway OVERALL RATING
3.6
Company: Reldata • www.reldata.com Cost: $43,907 Pro: Excellent technical support; good security design; very expandable. Cons: Poorly designed GUI hard to use and buggy; unmanaged external arrays; no snapshot agent support.
EzSANFiler XD34S OVERALL RATING
3.3
Company: Celeros • www.celeros.com Cost: $15,825 Pro: NAS and SAN capabilities; mixes SAS and SATA drives in same chassis; easy networking; expandable. Cons: iSCSI target configuration convoluted; no snapshot agent support; no HA capability; bad documentation.
NetCOR 7500 OVERALL RATING
3.3
Company: Kano • www.kanotechnologies.com Cost: $13,447 Pro: Built-in HA capabilities; six GigE ports per controller; easy expansion with mix of SATA and SAS drives. Cons: Limited snapshot features; no replication features.
DSN-3200-10 OVERALL RATING
3.1
Company: D-Link • www.dlink.com Cost: $12,475*** Pro: Lowest cost per gigabyte; offers eight Gigabit Ethernet data ports. Cons: Technical support level unacceptable; no HA capability; no snapshot capabilities; no expansion option.
SATABeast OVERALL RATING
3.1
Company: Nexsan Technologies • www.nexsan.com Cost: $67,500 Pro: Incredibly high density; fastest management in this test; very good performance for SATA-based system; built-in high-availability capabilities. Cons: Poor security model; no replication or snapshots; high-availability not transparent.

* Quantity: three ** Includes dual controllers *** Includes 15 user-added 1TB disks **** Includes DNF FS 16F Array
SCORECARD Interop-erability Data Protection Enterprise features Mgmt. Performance Green Final Score

20% 20% 20% 20% 15% 5%  
NetApp 5 5 4.5 2 5 3.5 4.2
Compellent Technologies 3.75 4.5 4 4.5 3.5 3.5 4.1
HP 4.25 3.5 5 3.5 4 4 4.1
Dell 4.25 3.5 4.5 3.5 4.5 3.5 4.0
LeftHand Networks 5 4.0 3.5 3.5 5 3 3.9
StoneFly 5