Skip Links

How to tell if your Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn efforts are paying off

Expion wins our test of eight enterprise-grade social media monitoring tools

By David Strom, Network World
March 25, 2013 06:10 AM ET

Network World - As businesses make more use of social networks, the number of engagement, analysis and monitoring tools has exploded. Enterprises are trying to understand their return on social media investments, to find out if their Twitter and Facebook marketing campaigns are actually delivering customers. They want to track social mentions across multiple networks and be responsive to both kudos and complaints.

We found nearly 100 products that fall into this emerging product category, which goes by a wide variety of names including social media monitoring, social CRM, social intelligence, enterprise listening platforms and media engagement. There are many tools that can perform a few tasks for free or nearly so, such as Bufferapp.com, Seesmic's Ping, Tweetreach.com and Tweetstats.com. But if you are looking for a more enterprise-grade tool, then you want something a bit more involved and capable. (We have published a list of all 90-plus vendors here.)

We tested eight for this review: Expion, Gremln, SimplyMeasured, SproutSocial, Sysomos Heartbeat, Ubervu, Viralheat, and Visible Technologies' Intelligence. These eight have a large base of business customers, even though you might not have heard of them. We also invited Google's Wildfire, Adobe's Marketing Cloud and Salesforce.com's Radian6, but the vendors declined to participate, either because they didn't have any way to allow a press review of their service or because they didn't have the resources to support our review process. (Watch a slideshow version of this story.)

[RELATED: Social media monitoring required to attend college]

The tools we looked at supposedly can answer questions such as:

  • Are your Twitter or Facebook marketing campaigns actually working?
  • Can you coordinate a social media campaign across an entire region for multiple retail locations?
  • When is the best time to schedule your Tweets and social status updates?
  • Should you invest more energy in particular networks for promoting your business?
  • Can you understand or track what your customers or competitors are saying about you online?
  • Is there something other than a simplistic Klout-style score that gives you more insight into what is going on with your brand on each social network?

Of the eight products, the overall best was Expion and tied at the bottom for the worst were SproutSocial and Visible Intelligence. Expion excelled in all three functional areas we tested: monitoring, posting and analysis. It could go both wide and deep and has some very sophisticated data filters to make it easier to focus on a particular collection of messages and act on them.

A close second was Ubervu, which offered almost as many features as Expion and at about the same price. One thing lacking from Expion is LinkedIn coverage, which Ubervu has.

The two lowest priced products were Gremln and Viralheat, and both are good places to get started with monitoring social media. Viralheat is just for single users but covers more social networks than Gremln.

Three of the products integrate various social media monitoring with Google Analytics: Sysomos, SproutSocial and SimplyMeasured. This is a powerful reason to choose one of these products, because they can coordinate social media campaigns with actual Web traffic stats.

Our Commenting Policies
Latest News
rssRss Feed
View more Latest News