Former Cisco data center chief debates Cisco data center senior director

Comments to a Cisco Data Center Network Blog titled - What Is NOT Networking for the Cloud, has former Cisco data center chief Jayshree Ullal - currently the CEO of datacenter cloud networking vendor Arista Networks, debating her former Cisco colleague, Douglas Gourlay - Senior Director of Cisco Data Center Marketing and Product Management.

Gourlay's blog states:

"What does Cloud Computing demand of a network? Some have asserted that, ‘it’s all about low latency’. Others ‘its all about big pipes’. And yet another group states, ‘it is all about the end point, the network is just plumbing.’ "The most important point, about Cloud Computing is that it is in the cloud and the cloud is the Internet. The Internet has some of the longest latencies, and by its very nature the most variability in latency (except maybe satellite transmissions). So how you buffer and flow control to address variable latency is important, and I would affirm in the cloud space more important than counting nanoseconds."

Ullal's comments argue:

"No matter what the term, 'Networking for the Cloud' or Arista’s 'Cloud Networking' - the inescapable architectural shift in the Data Center, should not be confused with the larger Internet or even Virtualization and Security. "Cloud Computing requires a holistic look at network performance. Our customers and Cloud network architects don’t design to one singular metric for cloud containerization. Its a balanced cloud for predictable/low latency (in nano secs to few microseconds), non blocking 1 or 10GE throughput, guaranteed packet delivery/buffers and appropriate uplinks. Not to mention the need for resilience and open extensibility. "By placing every possible buzz word in the DC 3.0 bucket (Unified Fabric, Virtualization, Cloud, Security, list goes on ), you have highlighted the complexity of DC 3.0 as opposed the simplicity, price/performance and beauty of clouds in a data center. "Bottom line, some thoughtful Cloud Network designs are needed to parse your words and mine."

View more of this ongoing debate.

What's your take and whose side are you leaning towards? BradReese.Com Cisco Refurbished

  1. Nortel employees speak out: Hopes of becoming multimillionaires dashed
  2. Message to Cisco: Happiness lies back in your own backyard
  3. Billion dollar financial fraud revealed within Satyam, a collaboration partner of Cisco
  4. China CCIE count grows 11 times more than U.S.
  5. Cisco goes Hollywood with product placements
  6. Cisco activates crisis management team as global manufacturing hits new low
  7. Is Cisco customer advocacy being thrown under the bus?
  8. Cisco ain't got the skills to make it in the consumer market
  9. 1% of Cisco products generate 50% of Cisco product revenue
  10. The mystery of the missing video of Cisco co-founders Bosack and Lerner discussing their termination
  11. View Brad Reese on Cisco Story Archives
Join the Network World communities on Facebook and LinkedIn to comment on topics that are top of mind.

Copyright © 2009 IDG Communications, Inc.