Did Alcatraz escapees survive? Computer program says they might have

Hydrology app may prove Alcatraz escapees could have survived; they may not want to show themselves however


It’s long been a mystery – could three escaped convicts housed at Alcatraz Island prison have survived a treacherous escape across San Francisco Bay?

First a little background: According to US Marshals history of the Alcatraz event, on the night of June 11, 1962, the three escaped through vents in the prison and made their way to the northeast part of the island, where they inflated the makeshift raft made from more than 50 raincoats and put on three life preservers and took to the water. Varied reports stated that the inmates either drowned or made their escape via nearby Angel Island. No bodies were ever found.

+More on Network World: +

A fourth inmate, Allen West, was involved in planning the escape, but he never made it out of his prison cell. The known details of the escape were provided by West during several interviews, the Marshals stated.

The elaborate escape plan was in the works for more than a year and aside from the life raft and life preservers, included the making of lifelike dummies to ruse guards on night bed checks and enlarged ventilation holes in their cell walls, which they used spoons to create and concealed with cardboard replicas of vent covers, the Marshals said.

This week Dutch scientists from Delft University of Technology presented findings from a computer modeling program they were working on, unrelated to the mystery, that demonstrated the escapees could have survived the journey.

From the Delft story on the research: “In hindsight, the best time to launch a boat from Alcatraz was [11:30 pm], one and a half hours later than has generally been assumed. A rubber boat leaving Alcatraz at [11:30 pm] would most likely have landed just north of the Golden Gate Bridge. The model also shows that debris in that scenario would be likely to wash up at Angel Island, exactly where one of the paddles and some personal belongings were found.

Olivier Hoes, a researcher at Delft University of Technology and a consultant with Nelen & Schuurmans, was actually working on analyzing the flood risk for large industrial facilities in San Francisco Bay at UC Berkeley. For that purpose, he modeled the bay area in considerable detail using 3Di, state-of-the-art hydraulic software. When he showed the results to his colleague Rolf Hut, a researcher at TU Delft, Hut realized that the hydraulic model could be used to shed new light at the Great Escape from Alcatraz. “To my surprise, that had never been done before, except in a famous episode of MythBusters. The only extra data we needed was the tide information for that night, which was quickly found.”

‘The simulations show that if the prisoners had left before 11:30, they would have had absolutely no chance of surviving. The strong currents would have taken them out to sea. However, if they left between 11:30 and midnight, there is a good chance they reached Horseshoe Bay north of the Golden Gate Bridge’, Fedor Baart, a hydraulic engineer at Deltares explained. The model predicts that any debris would then float back into the bay in the direction of Angel Island, exactly where the FBI found a paddle and some personal belongings.

‘Of course, this doesn’t prove this was what really happened, but the latest and best hydraulic modeling information indicates that it was certainly possible. We also suspect the prisoners may have left later than has always been assumed because an escape at 22.00 doesn’t fit in with where the paddle was found. And, of course, it is really intriguing that the famous TV show MythBusters also found that the most likely landing place was Horseshoe Bay,” concluded Hut in the Delft story.

Interestingly if they were to be found alive, the US Marshals office as recently as 2012 said they would be punished.

In 2012, the US Marshals Service says it remained "diligent in the manhunt for Frank Morris and brothers Clarence and John Anglin as they are the only men to escape from Alcatraz Island in San Francisco who remain unaccounted for."

"No matter where the leads take us, or how many man hours are spent on this historic case, the Marshals Service will continue to investigate to the fullest extent possible," said David Harlow, assistant director, U.S. Marshals Investigative Operations Division in in 2012. To back up the notion, the  Marshals said they will continue to pursue the escapees until they are either arrested, positively determined to be deceased or reach the age of 99. Morris, who was in prison for burglary of a bank would be 87 years old, Clarence Anglin who was in prison for armed robbery would be 83 and John Anglin was in Alcatraz for armed robbery as well, would be 84 if they managed to survive the escape, which has never been proven one way or the other.

The Marshals Service adopted the case from the FBI in 1979. Since that time, countless deputy U.S. marshals have worked the case and investigated thousands of leads in almost every state in the country and a few foreign countries. They used media venues such as the TV show America's Most Wanted to generate tips and additional investigative information. The possibility of survival steered investigators to unusual and detailed leads to suspected whereabouts of the escapees. One example occurred in 2010, when an unmarked grave, claimed to be that of an escapee, was exhumed but failed to offer positive identification.

In a 1993 interview with that program, US Marshals Service Acting Director John Twomey said, "We know they were young and vigorous, that they had the physical ability to survive and that they had a well-thought-out scheme."

+More on Network World: The fantastic world of steampunk technology+

The FBI wrote about the case in 2007 stating: Plenty of people have gone to great lengths to prove that the men could have survived, but the question remains: Did they? Our investigation at the time concluded otherwise, for the following reasons:

  • Crossing the Bay. Yes, youngsters have made the more than mile-long swim from Alcatraz to Angel Island. But with the strong currents and frigid Bay water, the odds were clearly against these men.
  • Three if by land. The plan, according to our prison informant, was to steal clothes and a car once on land. But we never uncovered any thefts like this despite the high-profile nature of the case.
  • Family ties. If the escapees had help, we couldn't substantiate it. The families appeared unlikely to even have the financial means to provide any real support.
  • Missing in action. For the 17 years we worked on the case, no credible evidence emerged to suggest the men were still alive, either in the U.S. or overseas.

Some interesting facts about Alcatraz:

  • During its 29 years of operation, the penitentiary claimed no prisoner had successfully escaped. A total of 36 prisoners made 14 escape attempts, two men trying twice; 23 were caught, six were shot and killed during their escape, two drowned, and five are listed as "missing and presumed drowned".
  • Among its myriad infamous prisoners, Alcatraz held Al Capone, George "Machine Gun" Kelly, Alvin "Creepy Karpis" Karpowicz and a man who has been in the news lately, James "Whitey" Bulger.
  • Clint Eastwood played Morris in the 1979 flick about the breakout, "Escape from Alcatraz."

Check out these other hot stories:

H: FBI: The Top 3 ways Congress could help fight tenacious cyber threats

Report: Significant technical trials remain before drones can safely access national airspace

Intelligence agency wants a superconducting, super cool, supercomputer

Are privacy and civil liberties a secondary concern for law enforcement?

DARPA looks to connect complex system security dots and wipe out malicious cyber attacks

US intelligence wants high-tech access to the most prodigious sensor of all: Humans

Copyright © 2014 IDG Communications, Inc.

The 10 most powerful companies in enterprise networking 2022