Wi-Fi products

5 Wi-Fi stumblers and analyzers for less than $100

wifi stumbler analyzers under 100 1

Wi-Fi stumblers and analyzers are a must-have when troubleshooting Wi-Fi interference and performance issues, or when simply checking channel usage on the wireless bands. They’re also needed for Wi-Fi site surveys during the network design and deployment phases, as well as for security audits to look for rogue or misconfigured access points.

Each tool gives you the basic wireless details of nearby access points: SSIDs, signal strength, channels, Media Access Control addresses, and security status. Most can even reveal “hidden” or non-broadcasted SSIDs. Some offer additional functionality, such as details of nearby wireless clients, raw 802.11 packet capturing, frame statistics, performance testing, and map-based surveying.

+ ALSO ON NETWORK WORLD: 7 free Wi-Fi stumbling and surveying tools +

Here we review five low-cost Wi-Fi stumblers and analyzers: Acrylic WiFi Professional, insider 4, NetSurveyor, Wi-Fi Scanner and WirelessMon. It should be noted that, with the exception of Acrylic WiFi Pro, these entry-level tools don’t show you the noise or signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) values like higher-priced enterprise solutions do. Here are a few quick takeaways:

-- If you’re looking for something really simple, consider the least expensive stumbler here: inSSIDer 4. It’s user-friendly, gives you channel recommendations and helps identify interfering access points. However, it doesn’t offer any saving or exporting. If you’re looking for something more advanced, particularly with the ability to detect non-802.11 interference, take a look at the inSSIDer Office edition. It comes with the Wi-Spy adapter to take full RF spectrum measures with inSSIDer in the Wi-Fi bands.

-- Acrylic WiFi Professional is a great option for more advanced wireless technicians since it can show the raw 802.11 frames, aid in penetration testing of Wi-Fi security, and even show the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) values of the access points. However, entry-level techs might be turned off by the lack of help and documentation.

-- If you want to check the Wi-Fi performance or prefer a stumbler that can generate reports, consider NetSurveyor Professional. However, since it doesn’t provide full channel or security details and doesn’t offer graphs for 5GHz, it’s not the best tool for general surveying.

-- If you’re looking for an inexpensive map-based survey tool, or a tool that can help detect non-802.11 interference, take a look at WirelessMon. However, keep in mind that detecting non-802.11 signals or interference does require the Wi-Spy RF spectrum adapter, just like with the inSSIDer Office tool.

-- And if you’re looking for a simple stumbler that also gives you details on frames counts, consider Wi-Fi Scanner from LizardSystems.

Here are the individual reviews:

wifi stumblers compared

Acrylic WiFi Professional

Tarlogic Security offers Acrylic WiFi Professional, a Wi-Fi stumbler and analyzer that supports packet capturing and password cracking, regularly priced at $26.99. You can download a free trial of the Professional edition but it’s limited to four days use. There’s also a free edition with less functionality and a heatmap Wi-Fi surveying tool as well.

When you open Acrylic WiFi Professional, you see the list of detected SSIDs. On top of the application you can toggle wireless capturing on and off, and toggle between the normal, monitor, and AirPcap modes. The monitor mode, also commonly called promiscuous mode, allows you to capture all wireless traffic; not just the traffic of your wireless connections.

In addition to the typical wireless information shown for the detected SSIDs, you see the Wi-Fi Protected Security (WPS) details for those that support it. It also can reveal hidden SSIDs, recognize larger channel-widths, and distinguish between PSK and enterprise security modes. You can give SSIDs aliases by adding them to the saved inventory list, useful to help you distinguish between real and rogue access points. We didn’t however, find any real filtering capabilities; just the ability to hide SSIDs and stations after a certain amount of time from when they were last seen.

Unlike most stumblers, Acrylic WiFi Professional can provide real SNR values when using an AirPcap device. The SNR values are highly useful when troubleshooting interference and performance issues and is usually only seen in high-priced enterprise tools.

acryllic wifi

The main screen of Acrylic WiFi Professional shows you the list of SSIDs and allows you to toggle through graphs and additional details.

On the bottom portion of the SSID list, you can tab between many graphs, lists, and details. One graph shows each SSID’s signal strength. Another shows network quality ratings and along with detailed descriptions, suggestions, and solutions.

Under the list of SSIDs, you also have a tab to see a list of further network details of each SSID, a list of network requests from clients, location settings if using GPS capturing, and a tab to use when testing password security with their built-in brute-force cracker.

From the main menu on the left of the application, you can tab between other screens. The Stations screen shows a list of all detected Wi-Fi devices and their details. The Packets screen shows the log of raw 802.11 packets and allows you to view the frame contents and details, which all can be saved and exported into a PCAP file. The Scripting screen is where you can generate scripts for use with the built-in brute-force password cracker.

Acrylic provides a few ways of saving and exporting collected data. You can save a PCAP file containing the raw 802.11 packets and also save the list of SSID details and graphs via export using the clipboard, HTML file, or images.

They provide some help and documentation on using the application, however it’s not organized that well and the full manual they provide online is only available in Spanish.

inSSIDer 4

MetaGeek provides a handful of Wi-Fi surveying, troubleshooting, and optimization tools. The inSSIDer 4 Wi-Fi stumbler, available for both Windows and Mac OS X, is priced at $19.99. No free trial is offered, but there’s a 30-day money back guarantee.

The inSSIDer 4 GUI is very simple and straightforward. On the top portion of the application you find the access point list, which can be filtered based upon SSID, MAC address, channel, or signal. However, you won’t find the ability to name the SSIDs or access points with aliases nor can you save or export the SSID list or details. Depending upon your wireless adapter and driver, it’s possible to detect and reveal hidden SSIDs, but it’s not officially supported by inSSIDer. However, larger channel-widths are recognized and security is distinguished between the PSK and enterprise modes.

On the bottom portion of the main screen, you see graphs showing channel usage and signal strength for both bands. Any SSIDs with larger channel-widths are depicted in the graph as well.

inssider

The main screen of inSSIDer 4 showing SSID details in the logical view.

You can toggle between grouping the access point entries by radio in physical view or grouping by SSID in logical view, which we found convenient. Physical grouping means each line on the list represents a single physical radio on an access point, which could be hosting more than one SSID, and is usually good when you are working with a single access point. Logical grouping means each line on the list represents a SSID, which could be broadcasted on more than one radio or access point, and designed for when working with multiple access points.

Among the usual access point details, you see the minimum and maximum supported data rates, which isn’t always shown by Wi-Fi stumblers. However, you’ll only find the signal strength given in negative dBm values; no additional percentage or signal bar indicator in the list of details.

On the access point list you can click on the column labels to sort the list using the values from that particular column. When you select a SSID or access point entry you see a signal strength graph and other details depends upon what view you’re in.

In physical view, clicking an entry shows you a list of the virtual SSIDs on that radio. To help you identify interfering access points, it also conveniently shows you the recommended channel for that particular radio and lists the strongest access point that’s on the same or an overlapping channel, if any.

In logical view, clicking an entry shows you a list of all the different access points that are broadcasting that particular SSID.

Though inSSIDer is a very simple program, it offers a good online user guide that explains the details and functionality while also providing general Wi-Fi troubleshooting tips.

NetSurveyor Professional

NetSurveyor Professional is just one wireless tool of many provided by Nuts About Networks. Priced at $34, it provides the Wi-Fi scanning functionality from their free edition, while adding performance testing features. They offer a fully functional trial, but you’re limited to opening the application 10 times.

After opening NetSurveyor Professional, you’re met with the Connection Analysis screen. In the upper-right corner is the list of up to five wireless adapters currently installed and stats on their connections, including RSSI in negative dBm values and throughput percentages relative to the maximum real-world data rate. The maximum rate is configurable and by default set to 23.8Mbps. In the upper-left corner is a heatmap or waterfall chart, also showing the throughput percentages of each adapter.

On the bottom portion of the Connection Analysis screen, you can toggle between four charts, or show all at once. The time course view shows a line graph of the throughput values over time for each adapter and the spectrogram view gives you different visual of the same data. There’s also a line graph showing connection breaks and a bar graph showing the average throughput and standard deviations of each connection.

netsurveyor

NetSurveyor Professional first shows you the stats and graphs of your wireless adapters.

On the Network Discovery screen is where you find typical Wi-Fi scanner or stumbler details. Though we found it could reveal hidden SSIDs, it doesn’t recognize larger channel-widths (even overlapping channels in 2.4GHz) nor distinguish between PSK and Enterprise security. Additionally, you won’t find any filtering functionality for the SSID list, besides hiding SSIDs from appearing on the graphs.

On the bottom portion of the Network Discovery screen, you can toggle between several graphs showing the signal levels and channel usage in different visual representations. However, none of the graphs show signal or channel usage for any access points in the 5GHz band, and even for 2.4GHz no channel overlapping is shown.

There are two ways in which you can save or log the results. First, you can create a report. This takes a snapshot of most of the current data and graphs and puts it into a PDF. The logging functionality allows you to record the capture so you can then replay it to see the synchronized connection stats and throughput graphs.

Though the GUI and operation are straightforward, they still offer thorough documentation via an online help link.

Wi-Fi Scanner

Wi-Fi Scanner is from LizardSystems, which also has several other network-related utilities. It serves as a basic Wi-Fi stumbler and gives detailed connection stats, which can also be used for troubleshooting. After the fully functional 30-day evaluation period, you can register for the free Basic edition with the connection statistic functionality disabled. The full Standard edition costs $79.95, which is relatively high when compared with similar tools.

When you open the application, you’re met with an attractive and user-friendly GUI. You can see the list of SSIDs on the top portion and to the left of that you can easily filter the list based upon signal quality, network type, security type, and wireless band. Though it distinguishes between PSK and Enterprise security and recognizes larger channel-widths, it doesn’t fully support 802.11ac.

On the bottom portion of the main screen, you can flip through a few graphs: combined signal strength of all SSIDs and then a graph showing channel usage and signal strength for each wireless bands.

Lizard

Wi-Fi Scanner opens to the SSID list and graphs, and allows for easy filtering on the main screen.

 

 

cutline: Wi-Fi Scanner opens to the SSID list and graphs, and allows for easy filtering on the main screen.

On the Wireless Information screen, you can see the details of the current wireless connection, which you can toggle between different wireless adapters. Line graphs and counters are also shown for various MAC and PHY layer frame types, including total transmitted, received, failed, and different encryption frames.

On the Wireless Information screen, you can click the Profiles tab on the right to view the list of wireless network profiles saved by Windows. This isn’t useful unless you’re running Windows 8 and later.

Though it’s not very apparent with Wi-Fi Scanner, you can export all data including the graph images. However, it’s a pretty crude way: you right-click on the data, copy to clipboard, and then paste into an appropriate program, such as a text editor, spreadsheet, or image editor.

Other than the exporting, everything else is self-explanatory. However, it would be nice if they offered some real documentation. Clicking the Help shortcut takes you to their support page, but the only information we could find is some FAQ.

Related:
1 2 Page 1
Page 1 of 2
The 10 most powerful companies in enterprise networking 2022