AT&T to 'lifelong customer:' Shut up & talk to the lawyers

Send a thoughtful suggestion to AT&T's chief exec, and what do you get? A letter from the company's lawyers suggesting that you quietly go away.

shhhhh quiet mouth lips

You don't need an MBA to know that in business, few things are more important than listening to your customers. So it's surprising that AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson, who earned an MBA from the University of Oklahoma, told a customer that AT&T isn't at all interested in his suggestions. Ever. In fact, if you send Stephenson an unsolicited suggestion, you'll get a similar response from his lawyers.

Randall Stephenson, AT&T Reuters/Kevin Lamarque

AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson

Sounds crazy, but it's true.

Tell it to the attorneys

Alfred Valrie, a resident of the Southern California town of El Sereno, had a couple of good ideas he thought he'd share with AT&T. A self-described lifelong AT&T customer, Valrie dropped a note to Stephenson:

"Hi. I have two suggestions. Please do not contact me in regards to these. These are suggestions. Allow unlimited data for DSL customers, particularly those in neighborhoods not serviced by U-verse. Bring back text messaging plans like 1,000 Messages for $10 or create a new plan like 500 Messages for $7."

You'd think an executive would be pleased as punch to get such a civilized note from a customer. Not Stephenson.

He referred Valrie's email to AT&T's legal department, which, according to a column in The Los Angeles Times, sent a response that read like this:

"AT&T has a policy of not entertaining unsolicited offers to adopt, analyze, develop, license or purchase third-party intellectual property ... from members of the general public. Therefore, we respectfully decline to consider your suggestion."

The letter was signed by Thomas A. Restaino, AT&T's chief intellectual property counsel. When LA Times columnist David Lazarus asked AT&T why it won't listen to customers, he got the following response:

"In the past, we've had customers send us unsolicited ideas and then later threaten to take legal action, claiming we stole their ideas," she explained. "That's why our responses have been a bit formal and legalistic. It's so we can protect ourselves."

T-Mo blasts AT&T

That is, of course, mind boggling.

john legere

T-Mobile CEO John Legere

When word of AT&T's behavior got out, T-Mobile's hyper-combative CEO John Legere jumped into the act. Legere had his team create an email address,, that collects ideas for AT&T services and sends the best ones on to Stephenson. The Twitter hashtag #IdeasforRandall is also being used to harvest ideas.

"It absolutely amazes me that Randall would tell a lifelong customer to basically go away and talk to my lawyers," Legere said in a statement. "I interact with customers on a daily basis so I can hear their ideas firsthand. It's called living in the 21st century."

I sometimes find Legere to be a bit ... bumptious. But this time he's right. As for Stephenson, I think he should have to forfeit that MBA.

This story, "AT&T to 'lifelong customer:' Shut up & talk to the lawyers" was originally published by CIO.


Copyright © 2015 IDG Communications, Inc.

The 10 most powerful companies in enterprise networking 2022