I am on vacation until Aug. 29
(Note: To fill the vacation void, we are dipping into the Buzzblog archives for some lighter fare and more personal items that I enjoyed writing for one reason or another.)
This was originally published on June 20, 2006:
Mac vs. PC ads miss the mark
My three 4-year-olds watch way too much television, but thanks to the good folks at Noggin (ask a parent of young children) they see very few commercials. Perhaps as a consequence, Emma, Grant and Max tend to find fascinating any commercials that they do see.
And one question from them pops up more often than any other: “What do they want us to buy?”
You might be surprised how often the answer isn’t obvious.
Such is the case with these new Apple ads featuring the ultra-hip “Mac” character and his nerdy stumblebum of a counterpart, “PC,” for reasons that are well articulated by Seth Stevenson, author of Slate’s “Ad Report Card.”
“I’m smack in the middle of the target demo,” Stevenson writes. “I’m a PC user, and I’ve often considered switching to an Apple. Thus, I feel equipped to say: These ads don’t work on me. They are conceptually brilliant, beautifully executed, and highly entertaining. But they don’t make me want to buy a Mac.”
Stevenson nails the why: A viewer is as likely as not to come away wanting to smack “Mac” as buy one.
“The ads pose a seemingly obvious question – would you rather be the laid-back young dude or the portly old dweeb? – but I found myself consistently giving the ‘wrong’ answer: I’d much sooner associate myself with” the “PC” actor than with “Mac,” Stevenson writes.
Another problem with the approach, which Stevenson doesn’t address, is that virtually everyone Apple hopes to attract as a customer already owns a PC – and many of us “PCs” no longer find amusing the idea that we’re a bunch of dupes. Tell me I’m a fool and then ask for my business? Not bloody likely.
Of course, there’s no telling what any individual is going to take from any single TV commercial. My son Grant asked this question after watching a spot for a financial services outfit that featured a muscular male bovine: “Do they want us to buy the bull?”
I laughed out loud … and only later did I realize that the best answer would have been: “Always, son, always.”
Not long afterward, I changed my mind about these ads – it’s allowed – and that was right around the time Bill Gates was losing his cool over them.
Welcome regulars and passersby. Here are a few more recent buzzblog items. And, if you’d like to receive Buzzblog via e-mail newsletter, here’s where to sign up. Follow me on Twitter here and on Google+ here.
- 16 milestones of a million, billion or more … from just the past month.
- Did Google+ ban cleavage-snuggling LEGO stormtrooper?
- “Have I reached the party to whom I am speaking?”
- Imagine your neighbor built a fake Apple store.
- Toyota systems automatically stops car before it can hit a pedestrian.
- A few suggestions for destroying the “indestructible botnet.”
- Monkey business with a camera sparks copyright debate.
- What Microsoft paid The Stones to help launch Windows 95.
- Pilots spar over wisdom of relying on an iPad in the cockpit.
- Tech ‘firsts’ that made a President’s day.
- 2011’s 25 Geekiest 25th Anniversaries.
