pmcnamara
News Editor

One problem with Google News

Opinion
Mar 29, 20071 min

My homepage is Google News. Use it all the time, every day.

But here’s one huge problem with a news aggregator that (reportedly) relies solely on software to make editorial judgments: You get headlines such as this one — “4 locals among Circuit City layoffs” — listed as the second most important business story of the moment. First paragraph:

Four workers at the Fort Collins Circuit City store, 4414 S. College Ave., were laid off Wednesday as part of a corporate-wide plan to cut 3,400 higher paid workers and replace them with lower-paid new hires.

Now please don’t think I’m picking on the Coloradoan here; I spent half my life working for a local newspaper and “the local angle,” as we like to call little nuggets such as those four layoff  victims, is what local journalism is all about.

But Google News isn’t a local news outlet.

Oh, sure, I can and did scan down to find a version of the same story written from a national perspective, but need to do that demonstrates once again why human editors get the big bucks.